THE GOVERNMENT GOADED THE PEOPLE · TO THE POINT OF MADNESS.

Mahatma GandhiLord Linlithgow

I must thank you warmly for your prompt reply to my letter of the 19th instant.

29 · I · 1943Printed pp. 139–141

THE GOVERNMENT GOADED THE PEOPLE
TO THE POINT OF MADNESS.

Dear Lord Linlithgow,

I must thank you warmly for your prompt reply to my letter of the 19th instant. I wish I could agree with you that your letter is clear. I am sure you do not wish to imply by clearness simply you hold a particular opinion strongly. I have pleaded and would continue to plead till the last breath that you should at least make an attempt to convince me of the validity of opinion you hold that the August resolution of the Congress is responsible for the popular violence that broke out on August 9 last and after even though it broke out after the wholesale arrest of principal leaders. Was not the drastic and unwarranted action of the Government responsible for the reported violence?

You have not even said what part of the August resolution is bad or offensive in your opinion. That resolution is in no way a retraction by the Congress of its policy of non-violence. It is definitely against Fascism in every shape or form. It tenders co-operation in war effort under circumstances

[p. 140]

which alone can make effective and nation-wide co-operation possible. Is all this open to reproach? Objection may be raised to that clause of the resolution which contemplated civil disobedience. But that by itself cannot constitute an objection since the principle of civil disobedience is impliedly conceded in what is known as the ‘Gandhi-Irwin Pact’. Even that civil disobedience was not to be started before knowing the result of the meeting for which I was to seek from you an appointment.

Then take the unproved and in my opinion unprovable charges hurled against the Congress and me by so responsible a Minister as the Secretary of State for India.

Surely, I can say with safety that it is for the Government to justify their action by solid evidence, not by mere ‘ipse dixit’.

But you throw in my face the facts of murders by persons reputed to be Congressmen. I see the fact of the murders as clearly as I hope, as you do. My answer is that the Government goaded the people to the point of madness. They started leonine violence in the shape of the arrests already referred to. That violence is not any the less so,

[p. 141]

because it is organised on a scale so gigantic that it displaces the Mosaic Law of tooth for tooth by that of ten thousand for one—not to mention the corollary of the Mosaic Law, i.e., of non-resistance as enunciated by Jesus Christ. I cannot interpret in any other manner the repressive measures of the all-powerful Government of India.

Add to this tale of woe the privations of the poor millions due to India-wide scarcity which I cannot help thinking might have been largely mitigated, if not altogether prevented, had there been a bona fide National Government responsible to a popularly elected assembly.

If then I cannot get soothing balm for my pain I must resort to the law prescribed for Satyagrahis, namely, a fast according to capacity. I must commence after the early morning breakfast of February 9, a fast for 21 days ending on March 2. Usually during my fasts, I take water with the addition of salts. But nowadays my system refused water. This time therefore I propose to add juices of citrus fruit to make water drinkable. For, my wish is not to fast unto death, but to survive the ordeal, if God so will. This fast can be ended sooner by the Government giving the needed relief.

I am not marking this letter personal as I did the two previous ones. They were in no way confidential. They were a mere personal appeal.

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 142 of the 1947 edition (printed page 139), showing letter 29.
Printed page 139 · scan leaf 142 of 154Open the full scan
Scan leaf 143 of the 1947 edition (printed page 140), showing letter 29.
Printed page 140 · scan leaf 143 of 154Open the full scan
Scan leaf 144 of the 1947 edition (printed page 141), showing letter 29.
Printed page 141 · scan leaf 144 of 154Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter 29 of 31 · printed pp. 139–141 · scan leaf 142 of 154

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
Famous Letters of Mahatma Gandhi, compiled and Edited by R. L. Khipple, M.A., 1947, pp. 139–141.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationMahatma Gandhi to Lord Linlithgow, 29 January 1943, “THE GOVERNMENT GOADED THE PEOPLE · TO THE POINT OF MADNESS.”. In Famous Letters of Mahatma Gandhi, compiled and Edited by R. L. Khipple, M.A. (Lahore: The Indian Printing Works, Kacheri Road), pp. 139–141. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/gandhi-famous-letters-1947/29/.

BibTeX@incollection{gandhi-famous-letters-1947-letter-0029,
  author    = {Mahatma Gandhi},
  title     = {THE GOVERNMENT GOADED THE PEOPLE · TO THE POINT OF MADNESS., 29 January 1943},
  booktitle = {Famous Letters of Mahatma Gandhi},
  publisher = {Lahore: The Indian Printing Works, Kacheri Road},
  year      = {1947},
  pages     = {139--141},
  note      = {Compiled and Edited by R. L. Khipple, M.A.. Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/gandhi-famous-letters-1947/29/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/gandhi-famous-letters-1947/29/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.