Letter 57

C. H. CLAUDY

No boy or girl gets into a high school without a lot of well-intentioned people preaching…

Printed pp. 61–62

No boy or girl gets into a high school without a lot of well-intentioned people preaching the advantages of fair play to them. Few of them need to have it taught them, as far as it applies to sport; any foot ball player, any girl on a basket ball team, knows that unfair play ruins the fun for every one, and takes away all the joy of winning.

But sometimes girls and boys want concrete instances of how lack of fair play hurts the bigger game they must play when they leave school; with examples of crooked men “getting away with it” and graft in politics making people rich without effort, it is not surprising that they ask.

If the question is analyzed, isn’t it easily to be seen that it is predicated upon the fact that the rewards of unfair grown-up play are not worth having? The boy who cheats in tennis knows his victory is ashes in his mouth. The girl who cribs an answer instead of working for it gets no joy out of a good mark. Is there any reason to suppose that the grafter gets real joy from his ill-won money, or the crook any happiness out of what he steals?

I once stood in a curved line of some three hundred delegates to a convention waiting for a photographer with one of those revolving cameras to make a panoramic picture. After man number one had made his exposure, man number two came along with his camera. While man number two was getting his instrument fixed, man number one went along the line handing out his business cards, hoping to sell many pictures. Then man number two began his exposure; one of those slow affairs where the camera turns on its axis. Right in the middle of it, man number one ran in front of the camera and held his hand up in front of the lens, with the obvious intention of doing what he did do—spoil the picture man number two was trying to make.

[p. 62]

There was a moment of silence, then a confused growl of protest. And then an odd sight—a shower of white as every one of the crowd of people tore up the cards man number one had handed out. Man number two was called on to make another picture—man number one was literally hissed off the ground—and the busy three hundred stood around and waited until man number two could send back for a new film, and make the picture.

That was a concrete case, absurdly simple, but easy to look at, where unfair play brought its own penalty.

When we get you all in a hall where you can't move because of discipline, and take the unfair advantage of you of preaching, it isn't, truly, because we think you are not right thinking, honest, just as good as we are. It often sounds that way, I know. But the way it is meant is so different. Shakespeare makes Cassius speak of himself to Brutus as an “elder Soldier, not a better.” And that is what we who preach feel; it is what I am feeling now, as I preach fair play to you. It's not because I think you don't want to play fair; it gets you nowhere (not even if you win riches by it) to play crooked.

I don't blame you a bit if you don't like this sort of talk, but, dear Group, you asked for it. I hardly know what to give you; so I give you of my experience, and at the same time, ask your forgiveness if it comes in the form of a sermon!

C. H. CLAUDY

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 85 of the 1925 edition (printed page 61), showing letter 57.
Printed page 61 · scan leaf 85 of 392Open the full scan
Scan leaf 86 of the 1925 edition (printed page 62), showing letter 57.
Printed page 62 · scan leaf 86 of 392Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter 57 of 326 · printed pp. 61–62 · scan leaf 85 of 392

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
Letters from Famous People, 1925, pp. 61–62.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationC. H. CLAUDY, “Letter 57”. In Letters from Famous People (New York; Chicago; San Francisco; Boston; London: The Gregg Publishing Company, 1925), pp. 61–62. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/letters-from-famous-people-1925/57/.

BibTeX@incollection{letters-from-famous-people-1925-letter-0057,
  author    = {C. H. CLAUDY},
  title     = {Letter 57, undated},
  booktitle = {Letters from Famous People},
  publisher = {New York; Chicago; San Francisco; Boston; London: The Gregg Publishing Company, 1925},
  year      = {1925},
  pages     = {61--62},
  note      = {Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/letters-from-famous-people-1925/57/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/letters-from-famous-people-1925/57/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.