Letter 1
Clearly James Mill had been suffering from gout, for farther on in the same letter…
" If in the meantime any such thing as dying should happen to you (for we are all mortal ! ! ! !), you having however between the act of such dying as aforesaid and the act of receiving these presents, time to make your will (which to the purpose in question may be done by word of mouth, but if you cannot write it yourself better have it set down in writing and read to you), if you will appoint me guardian to Mr. John Stuart Mill, I will, in the event of his father's being disposed of elsewhere, take
[p. xvi]him to Q. S. P.1 and there or elsewhere, by whipping or otherwise, do whatsoever may seem most necessary and proper, for teaching him to make all proper distinctions, such as between the Devil and the Holy Ghost, and how to make Codes and Encyclopædias, and whatsoever else may be proper to be made, so long as I remain an inhabitant of this vale of tears, after which—but this must remain for God's providence to determine. . . ."
Clearly James Mill had been suffering from gout, for farther on in the same letter, Bentham offers to "come and sit with you, and help worship Mistink,2 and during the armistice of your arm, help whip Mr. John Mill."
To this Mill replied : 3 "I take your offer quite seriously, and then we may perhaps leave him a successor worthy of both of us."
From the eighth to the twelfth year Mill's education was carried forward on the same inexorable plan. The list of classical authors read during this period would be tedious to enumerate ; geometry and algebra were included in the curriculum, as also the differential calculus and other branches of the higher mathematics. He was exceedingly fond of history ; and while he was still eleven he had composed a Roman History, "picked out of Hooke" ; an "Abridgment of the Ancient Universal History" ; a "History of Holland" ; and a "History of the Roman Government," compiled from Livy and Dionysius. At twelve, he began logic and read the "Organon," though he observes that he "profited little by the Posterior Analytics." He read several Latin treatises on the scholastic logic.
In 1818 the "History of India" was published, and in the following year James Mill received his appointment to the India House. But his new duties did not cause him to relax the rigour of his son's education. When the latter was thirteen years of age, he took him through a complete course of political economy.
[p. xvii]The mode of instruction in political economy adopted by James Mill well exemplifies the methods of his teaching. To impart to a child of thirteen knowledge of a subject naturally so abstruse, and so forbidding to a youthful mind, involved all the grave dangers which “cramming” inevitably brings—a weakening of the intelligence by an undue tax on the receptive powers of the pupil. But Mill took care that his education should not degenerate into mere blind cramming. There was at that time no text-book which embodied the most recent results of economic science; Ricardo’s great work had not yet been published. So Mill, in the course of his daily walks with his son, delivered expositions to him on the subject, which John had to write out afterwards and hand to his father next day. The notes thus accumulated served as a basis for the “Elements of Political Economy” which James Mill subsequently wrote. These notes had to be written over and over again before the exacting father was satisfied.
When John had reached the age of fourteen, there occurred a break in his life which marks the end of his first period of education. He was invited by Sir Samuel Bentham, brother of Jeremy Bentham, for a six months’ visit in the South of France; and the invitation being subsequently extended to twelve months, he was able to spend a year in gaining experience of the world from a totally new aspect. It may easily be imagined that a change from the strenuous and intellectual, though narrow, outlook of his father’s household had become well-nigh a necessity. Life hitherto had been for him a purely intellectual experience. If it had been marred by no unhappiness or misery, neither had it brought any pleasures or intensity of feeling. Can we wonder, then, at the profound impression produced upon his young and ardent mind, when he first gazed upon the grand mountain scenery of the Pyrenees? Here was a novel sensation indeed! Here was something, not intellectual, which yet produced a hitherto unexperienced elation of soul. Here, for the first time, his virgin emotions
[p. xviii]were deeply stirred; the first ray of sunshine fell upon that germ in his character which afterwards sprang up, leading him to rebel against his father's creed and throw over the crabbed doctrines of the early utilitarians.
His studies, however, were not discontinued during his residence in France. Chemistry, zoology, metaphysics, logic, were a few of the subjects to which he then devoted himself; while he acquired at the same time a thorough acquaintance with the French language, his proficiency in which appears in the letters to distinguished Frenchmen scattered through the present volumes. He returned to England in 1821, and thereafter the course of his former studies was resumed. Psychology now occupied a great share of his attention. He studied Roman law with John Austin, and at the age of fifteen a mental revolution was wrought in him by the reading of Dumont's “Traité de Législation,” in which work the principal speculations of Bentham were interpreted to the world. This book supplied to Mill a system of philosophy; it focussed his opinions, and gave him a creed, not drily maintained by the intellect, but enthusiastically supported by the whole mind. This doubtless marks the stage at which he first began to think for himself, to rely upon his own opinions, to take the first and most arduous step in his emancipation from the bondage of authority. With many persons this stage has been reached, as it was in Mill, by a sudden revolution, which is often delayed till comparatively late in life; with others it is a slow growth; while with the great majority it is never reached at all.
From this time forward Mill's intellectual cultivation was carried on by writing even more than by reading. He committed to paper various essays on political or historical subjects, which, besides the educative effect of preparing them, led to instructive conversations with his father. From this time also he commenced to converse with the able men collected round his father. He formed a small society of young men who, like himself, had fallen
[p. xix]under the influence of Bentham and James Mill. To this society he gave the name of the Utilitarian Society ; and the label thus selected gradually became adopted into the language to designate the system of views held by these thinkers. At the age of seventeen he entered upon his professional career with an appointment from the East India Company immediately under his father ; in which service he was destined to remain for thirty-five years, until the abolition of the Company in 1858.
The commencement of Mill's literary activities dates from the foundation of the Westminster Review in 1824. Before that time he had written a few short articles in one or two newspapers, but they were of little importance. In 1823 Bentham formed the project of starting a review which should act as a vehicle for the expression of the views held by him and his disciples. At the same period, there happened to be projected a scheme for the foundation of a purely literary journal ; and the two projects were amalgamated, resulting in the issue of the first number of the Westminster Review in April 1824. It attracted immediate notice, mainly on account of an article by James Mill criticising the Edinburgh Review since its foundation. The attack on the Edinburgh was continued by the son in the second number ; and thenceforward he continued to be closely associated with the Review, which took its place as the special organ of “ Philosophic Radicalism.”
About the beginning of 1825 a new work was undertaken by Mill—that of editing and preparing for the press Bentham's book on Evidence. Bentham had commenced the execution of this work no less than three times, but on each occasion had failed to complete it. His papers had already been used by Dumont as a foundation for his “Traité des Preuves Judiciaires” ; and he now entrusted Mill with the task of condensing the masses of manuscript into a single treatise. The chief value to Mill of this work was undoubtedly the opportunity which it afforded of cultivating his powers of composition. The practice which he derived from it
[p. xx]benefited him to such an extent that he was able to say, “ Everything which I wrote subsequently to this editorial employment was markedly superior to anything that I had written before it.”
It was about this time that Mill tells us he passed through a critical period of nervous depression and mental inertia. He seems to have been troubled with all sorts of curious fancies. He was, for instance, “ seriously tormented by the thought of the exhaustibility of musical combinations. The octave consists only of five tones and two semi-tones, which can be put together in only a limited number of ways, of which but a small proportion are beautiful: most of these, it seemed to me, must have been already discovered, and there could not be room for a long succession of Mozarts and Webers to strike out, as these had done, entirely new and surprisingly rich veins of musical beauty.” He awoke from this condition to a reaction from the fervent Benthamism which had till then possessed him. The reaction was instituted by his chancing to open a copy of Wordsworth, and deriving great enjoyment from it. Thereupon his mind was opened to new ideas from all quarters; he scandalised his former friends by studying Coleridge, Goethe, and Carlyle. He was greatly influenced by the theories of the St. Simonians, who were then beginning to attract attention in France; and he very soon came under the spell of Auguste Comte.
From this time onward the “Letters” supply a tolerably connected history of Mill’s life; and I need only touch lightly on the more important events of his career. In 1830 he was introduced to Mrs. Taylor, and thus commenced the great affection of his life. After twenty years of the closest intimacy, the death of Mrs. Taylor’s husband left her free to marry Mill. But during this time Mill’s reputation suffered greatly through his connection with her. His father “taxed him with being in love with another man’s wife,” and expressed “ his strong disapproval of the affair.”1 Mill’s
[p. xxi]affection was intense, and when they ultimately married, they withdrew almost entirely from society. The dedication to the “Liberty,” the inscription on her tomb at Avignon, the “Autobiography,” indicate the intensity of feeling.
In 1835 Sir William Molesworth founded the London Review, on the understanding that Mill should act as editor. Soon afterwards Molesworth bought the Westminster Review and united it with the London, which was conducted by Mill till 1840 under the title of the London and Westminster Review. It was of course used to propagate the views of the Philosophic Radicals; but Mill had no intention of confining it to one narrow school of thought, and admitted articles by such men as Carlyle and John Sterling. The Review never paid its way; after two or three years Molesworth determined to part with it, and it was acquired by Mill himself. He kept it till 1840, when he passed it on to one of the most regular of its contributors. The “Logic” was published in the spring of 1843. It was offered to Murray but refused by him, and was finally published by the firm of Parker. On the completion of the “Logic,” he turned his thoughts to a work on “Ethology,” or the science of character; but, failing to make anything of it, turned his attention to writing the “Political Economy,” which was published in 1848. All this time he continued his career at the India House, and in 1856 reached the highest place in the office. He only enjoyed that position for two years; on the abolition of the East India Company in 1858, he retired on a pension of £1500 a year. In the same year he suffered the crowning calamity of his life, namely, his wife’s death at Avignon, while on their way to the South of France.
The shock was, indeed, terrible. Mill took a cottage in the district of St. Véran, near Avignon, close to her tomb, and for most of the remainder of his life made this his home, spending only a short part of each year at his house at Blackheath. Miss Helen Taylor, Mrs. Mill’s daughter, now kept house for her stepfather;
[p. xxii]and the tranquillity of his subsequent life was only interrupted during the three years (1865–1868) that he represented Westminster in the House of Commons. The story of his election and subsequent defeat are recorded in detail in the “Letters,” and I need do no more than allude to it.
During his retirement he wrote several works. The most important is that on “Liberty,” which he believed was “likely to survive longer than anything else that I have written (with the possible exception of the ‘Logic’).” It was the joint product, he tells us, of himself and his wife, and was published immediately after her death. Among his other productions were the “Utilitarianism,” the “Examination of Sir William Hamilton’s Philosophy,” the “Representative Government,” the “Subjection of Women.” He died on 8th May 1873. During his life he had suffered from pulmonary tuberculosis, which profoundly injured one lung, but proceeded no further. A few days before his death he went on a botanical excursion with some friends ; and after a long walk, feeling tired, he adopted the unusual course of taking a carriage home. The unaccustomed drive at night in his over-fatigued condition gave him a chill, which developed into erysipelas—a disease endemic around Avignon in consequence of the marshes in the neighbourhood. The disease soon attacked the brain, and killed him in a day or two.
Mill’s education was so remarkable that we turn with interest to an analysis of his character. We find it to be, indeed, very different from anything that his published works would suggest. So far from being a mere “logic-chopping machine,” Mill was a man of such intensity and depth of feeling as is rarely to be met with. In vain do we search in his character for those weaknesses, whether of emotion or of will, that are so often found to accompany transcendent intellectual power. Mill’s superiority of intellect was not derived from any sapping of other departments of his mind. He was not, like Herbert Spencer, deficient in power of application to
[p. xxiii]disagreeable subjects, nor in the active and volitional side of mind; nor was he, like Jeremy Bentham, or James Mill, or Alexander Bain, a man of low emotional susceptibility. Mill's emotional history is perhaps the most remarkable element of a remarkable personality. His upbringing, as we have seen, was carried out without the smallest reference to emotional cultivation. From the earliest years he was absorbed in intellectual pursuits; there was no outlet for the natural affections of his childhood. True, he had brothers and sisters; but his relation to them was rather that of teacher than of playmate. “I never was a boy,” he wrote sadly;1 for almost his entire waking hours were applied to study, and relaxation would have brought down upon him the austere censure of his father. That he was bound to his father by strong ties there can be no question. But the ties were not the ties of love; they were constituted by the cold sentiments of respect and awe, and the enthralling influence of a powerful personality upon the unformed mind of a child. Yet the large endowment of feeling which Nature had implanted in his youthful mind was not extirpated by this radical treatment. It was perhaps overlaid and rendered latent for a time. But as the boy grew older it gradually asserted itself with increasing insistence. I have already pointed out how profoundly he was affected by the mountain scenery of the Pyrenees. Even in the most sectarian period of his Benthamism, a chance reading of Pope's “Essay on Man,” promulgating views in every respect contrary to his own, wrought a vivid effect upon his imagination. Later still, his admiration of Wordsworth heralded and symbolised the breach which was shortly to take place with his father's views. And then there came the warm friendships with Carlyle and with John Sterling, friendships cemented by true affection, and not owing their strength to mere intellectual community. But the culminating point of his increasing emotional fervour was reached when he became acquainted
[p. xxiv]with Mrs. Taylor. Then, indeed, the pent-up emotions burst the bonds which a cramped education had set to them ; then indeed did they break forth with a torrent of irresistible force which carried all before it. Let me not here be misunderstood. The passion which Mill conceived for Mrs. Taylor had in it nothing that was vulgar or inclined to sensuality. It is obvious, in fact, from his published writings, that Mill greatly under-estimated the power of sensual passion in the motives of the average of mankind. In his views on the question of population, he proposed as a remedial measure a continence between married couples which betokened little conception of the power of the lower feelings in human nature. Close students of Mill, such as Leslie Stephen, Alexander Bain, and Professor Ashley, have remarked on the low degree of sensuality which inspired Mill. And I am able to add to the weight of their opinion the evidence which I have had before me, in the whole series of letters written by Mill to his wife. They are letters inspired by the most intense emotion ; in them Mill pours out his whole soul with the most absolute unreservedness ; the uncertain flicker of feeling which had survived his education has blazed out into a roaring flame ; but from beginning to end there is nowhere a suggestion of anything but the highest and noblest sentiments. The truth is, that he set her up as an idol and worshipped her. Had the affair descended to the commonplace level of a guilty intrigue, the spiritual aspect on which his mind so deeply dwelt would have been dissipated—the idol would have fallen shattered at his feet.
Mill's emotional bent appears in other dressings besides his love for his wife. His sympathy with persons was so keen that he was often led to express, in communication with them, a greater degree of agreement than he actually felt. Of this several instances will be noticed in the “ Letters.” Emotional fervour, again, was the origin of his social and political interests. A disinterested desire for the improvement of the condition of humanity was one
[p. xxv]of the fundamental sentiments of Mill's mind. He was a humanitarian of the highest type. His political and economic studies were only in part prompted by the truly scientific spirit whose sole purpose is the discovery of truth. Far more were they undertaken to satisfy his restless desire to improve the lot of mankind. As I have already observed, Mill's life shows a steady expansion of the emotional sphere, following on the artificial constriction caused by his education. In 1843, when he was a comparatively young man, he published the “ Logic,” the most purely scientific and the least affected by emotion of any of his works. From there he advanced to “ Ethology,” or a science of character ; but abandoning this, advanced again to the “ Political Economy,” which was published in 1848. In the “ Political Economy ” the love of scientific truth is still the dominant note ; but it has more emotional colouring than the “ Logic.” The “ Letters ” show how, as time went on, Mill's interests were more and more monopolised by his desire for human welfare. I discern here a great difference between Mill and his father. James Mill, vehement Radical as he was, cared less for humanity than his son. Bentham said of him that his political opinions resulted less from love of the many than from hatred of the few ;1 and however indignantly his son may have repudiated the suggestion, I suspect that it contains some measure of truth. However this may be, I think I have said sufficient to show how largely John Stuart Mill's life was inspired by feeling and emotion.
We are apt to imagine, as indeed we have some grounds for doing, that the emotional temperament carries with it a dreamy and inactive disposition in the practical affairs of life. But here, as so often in the study of Mill's character, we find our à priori anticipations altogether off the mark. For Mill possessed an endowment of practical energy to a degree far higher than the average. His life throughout was intense ; his output of literary work was astonishing ; he scarcely ever appeared to require rest.
[p. xxvi]The diary which he kept while staying with Sir Samuel Bentham in France serves to illustrate the strenuous manner in which his days were spent. I quote from Bain : 1—
“ 5th.—Rose at 5 ; too rainy for bathing. Five chapters of Voltaire ; from 7½ till 8½, Mr. G. corrects his French exercises, which had got into arrears as regards correction ; Music-master came ; at 9½ began new exercises (French) ; puts his room in order ; at 11¼ took out Lucian and finished Necyomantia ; five propositions of Legendre, renewed expressions of his superiority to all other geometers ; practises music-lessons ; Thomson’s Chemistry, makes out various Chemical Tables, the drift not explained ; at 3¼, tries several propositions in West (Algebra), and made out two that he had formerly failed in ; begins a table of 58 rivers in France, to show what departments each passes through, and the chief towns on their banks ; 4, dined ; finishes Chemical Table ; dancing lesson ; supped. . . . 6th.—Rose at 6 ; no bathing ; five chapters of Voltaire ; a quarter of an hour to West’s problems ; lesson in Music (Principes) ; problems resumed ; breakfasted, and tried problem again till 10¼ ; French exercises till 11 ; began to correct his Dialogue, formerly mentioned, till 12¼ ; summoned to dress for going out to call ; has found a French master ; at 1¼, returned and corrected Dialogue till 3¼ ; Thomson till 4 (dinner), resumed till 6 ; Mr. G. corrects his French exercises ; went out for his French lesson, but the master did not teach on Sundays and Thursdays ; back to Thomson till 8 ; repeated fables to Mr. G. ; miscellaneous affairs ; supped ; journal always written just before going to bed. 7th.— Rose 5¾ ; five chapters Voltaire till 7 ; till 7¼, 46 lines of Virgil ; till 8, Lucian’s Jupiter Confutatus ; goes on a family errand ; Music-lesson till 9 (Principes) ; Lucian continued till 9½, and finished after breakfast at 10¼ ; a call required him to dress ; read Thomson and made tables till 12¼ ; seven propositions of Legendre . . . ; till 1½, wrote exercises and various miscellanies ; till 2½, the treatise
[p. xxvii]on Adverbs; till 3¾, Thomson ; Livre Géographique and Miscellanies till 5. . . . 9th.—Rose at 5 ; five chapters of Voltaire ; 6¾, Adverbs ; 7¾, the Prometheus of Lucian ; 8½ till 9, first lesson of Solféges, together with Principes ; continued Prometheus till breakfast. . . ."
Perhaps the most interesting side of Mill's character is reached when we come to estimate his intellectual qualities. By far the most striking intellectual peculiarity which he exhibited was his marvellous receptivity. It is often the case that men who have been distinguished for originality and power of synthetic or analytic reasoning show little aptitude for absorbing the ideas of others. Their mind appears to run so strongly on its own course that in general it is little affected by what other people may be thinking or doing. The intense natural concentration of an original thinker upon his own line of thought often cannot be diverted to aspects foreign to that line of thought, even by a conscious effort on his own part. Let us compare, for instance, Mill's method of going to work with the profoundly different method of Herbert Spencer. Mill was, as I have said, receptive to an extraordinary degree ; he was for ever studying the works of others, reading on an enormous scale, a scholar in the truest sense of the word. Spencer, on the other hand, was almost completely inaccessible to ideas out of harmony with his natural modes of thought. He scarcely read at all ; when he did it was usually novels ; for many years of his life he never succeeded in reading a serious book for a longer period than an hour at a stretch. Spencer, in fact, never studied ; his philosophy welled up of its own accord from the depths of his mind ; it was a spontaneous outgrowth from his experience of life. He had a natural facility for attracting from every quarter facts which bore upon any theory he was promulgating, though without any effort to himself. It follows from this habit of mind that Spencer, though he could accumulate great stores of knowledge on any subject on which he had theorised, was plunged in abysmal ignorance on subjects on which he had formed no theory. Of history he knew nothing, of English literature
[p. xxviii]very little, of German literature not a word. The difference between him and Mill could scarcely be more marked.
A further difference in their manner of going to work is of great interest. When George Eliot asked Spencer how it was that he had no wrinkles on his forehead, as might be expected in one who had thought deeply, he replied that it was because he was never puzzled. His inactive disposition recoiled from the notion of wrestling with a problem in an attempt to solve it. Whenever he was confronted with a problem whose solution was not obvious to him he would push it aside, and abandon all conscious effort to solve it. But the matter would not usually be entirely lost sight of ; it would stick in the back of his mind, and by-and-by, very likely while thinking of something else, a little inward flash would occur, rendering the solution somewhat less obscure than it was before. With the lapse of time other flashes would follow ; and after several years, maybe, the solution of that problem would be set forth with the marvellous lucidity that Spencer commanded, as an integral portion of his system of philosophy. This is what we describe as true genius ; no puzzling, no conscious effort, no weary drudgery or labour, nothing that education can ever supply ; simply a succession of sudden inward flashes illuminating the whole of the darkened field.
How does this method compare with the method of John Stuart Mill ? The contrast is indeed great. Mill describes how he acquired “ the mental habit to which I attribute all that I have ever done, or ever shall do, in speculation ; that of never abandoning a puzzle, but again and again returning to it until it was cleared up ; never allowing obscure corners of a subject to remain unexplored because they did not appear important ; never thinking that I perfectly understood any part of a subject until I understood the whole.” In short, Mill’s method was that of conscious and vehement effort directed towards the end he had in view. He solved his problems by laborious application and study ;
[p. xxix]the very reverse of the brilliant and facile methods of Spencer.
A further characteristic difference between the two men is found when we inquire how each came by his literary style. Both had styles of exceptional lucidity and ease, but they were acquired in totally opposite ways. Spencer, after his manner, never studied style at all from the practical point of view, though he propounded a philosophic theory of it (“Essays,” vol. ii.). In “Facts and Comments,” pp. 78, 79, he says: “I have never studied style.” “It never occurred to me . . . to take any author as a model. Indeed, the thought of moulding my style upon the style of any one else is utterly incongruous with my constitutional disregard of authority.” “I may fitly say of my own style that from the beginning it has been unpremeditated. The thought of style, considered as an end in itself, has rarely if ever been present.” Mill, on the other hand, cultivated his style “by the assiduous reading of other writers, both French and English, who combined, in a remarkable degree, ease with force, such as Goldsmith, Fielding, Pascal, Voltaire, and Courier.”1 Bain remarks of him:2 “The undoubted excellence of his mature style was arrived at by a series of efforts that may well be celebrated among triumphs of perseverance.”
The education supplied to the two in their youth was just such as happened to be adapted to the qualities of each. Mill’s education was, as we have seen, an interminable round of study and effort. Not a moment was wasted; and he ascribes his own success to the fact that he entered on life with a knowledge that was a quarter of a century in advance of his competitors. Spencer, idle as a man, was idle also as a boy. He learnt very little, and nothing but what he liked; he could not go up to a university on account of the impossibility of his passing the entrance examinations. He entered life with a knowledge far inferior to that of
[p. xxx]his competitors ; but he had what they had not, for Nature had endowed him with an ability and self-confidence which far more than compensated for his lack of learning and education.
These observations bring me to the proposition that I now wish to lay down ; namely, that Mill's success was due far more to the rigour of his father's education than to any inborn genius of his own. That he would probably have admitted this himself may be inferred from the following passage in the “Autobiography” :—
“ If I had been by nature extremely quick of apprehension, or had possessed a very active and retentive memory, or were of a remarkably active and energetic character, the trial would not be conclusive ; but in all these natural gifts I am rather below than above par ; what I could do, could assuredly be done by any boy or girl of average capacity and healthy physical constitution ; and if I have accomplished anything, I owe it, among other fortunate circumstances, to the fact that through the early training bestowed on me by my father, I started, I may fairly say, with an advantage of a quarter of a century over my contemporaries.”
Mill, then, himself admits that he was not by nature highly endowed with respect to those qualities for which he afterwards became famous. Their development in him was due to the continual forcing to which he had been subjected in early life, and to the habits of abnegation and concentration thus acquired. Without his education, he would have done little or nothing. He lacked the characteristic of inborn genius, which shines out independently of education or acquirements. Though I should not accept Mill's belief that what he could do could be done by any boy or girl of average capacity and healthy physical constitution, still there seems to me no doubt that Mill's success was grounded on the marvellous extent of his acquirements and painstaking industry.
Summing up this estimate of Mill's character, we find that he greatly excelled the average of mankind in all the higher qualities of mind—in intellectual power, in concentration
[p. xxxi], in emotional strength, in will-power, and in active energy. That a man of so high a nervous development should be lacking on other sides is inevitable. I have already pointed out the low development of sensuality as compared with the average of mankind. That lack of sensuality is betrayed, not only in his estimate of the force of sexual passion, but in his indifference to luxuries of every kind. Bain observes:1—
“ He was exceedingly temperate as regarded the table; there was nothing of the gourmand superadded to his healthy appetite. To have seen his simple breakfast at the India House, and to couple with that his entire abstinence from eating or drinking till his plain dinner at six o'clock,—would be decisive of his moderation in the pleasures of the palate.”
A further deficiency, that is no doubt to be correlated with his intense mental development, was his poor physical development. He must have been born into the world with the constitution of a giant. Had he not been developed intellectually, he would probably have grown up with high muscular and athletic powers. But all the strength of his constitution was drafted off to the nervous system;2 and we find him throughout life threatened by consumption. He suffered also from a ceaseless twitching of the eyelid over one eye—evidence enough how great was the strain which that overwhelming intellectual burden cast upon his physical constitution.
I have attempted to set forth the powers of mind and body which made Mill a great man. I am aware that, in doing so, I have only dealt with one half of the case. The achievement of greatness does not depend on the individual alone, but to at least an equal extent upon the environment in which he is placed.
[p. xxxii]We have, then, to inquire what sort of an environment and what sort of times they were into which Mill was born. I think that much light is thrown on his success by such an inquiry. For he came in, so to speak, on the crest of a wave of democratic sentiment. Parliamentary Reform and the rights of the people, as against the aristocracy, were the chief political cries ; and the Liberal party was slowly coming into existence to enforce the claims of the people against the two older parties which had hitherto monopolised the government of the country. Mill had inherited from his father an intense belief in democratic institutions, with no small share of his father's detestation of the governing classes. Besides being deeply imbued with the sentiments that prevailed at the time, he had, as we have seen, the advantage of an education which enabled him to give scientific expression to the Radical spirit growing up about him. No wonder that he soon became the accepted champion and philosopher of the new school of thought.
It is unnecessary to state in detail what were the chief maxims espoused by this new school. Mill's politics differed widely in method from those of his father, though the conclusions were not dissimilar. James Mill's politics were wholly the product of a few general principles, which he received from Bentham and pushed to their extreme logical conclusions. John Mill's driving energy, on the contrary, was derived from his intense desire to ameliorate the lot of the working classes. It was this that he had constantly before his mind, rather than any general principles ; and this is to a great extent the cause of his apparent changeability with regard to various fundamental principles. There has been much discussion as to Mill's attitude towards Socialism ; but the letters herewith published make the matter perfectly clear. He was not in principle opposed to Socialism. As he says in his “ Autobiography ” : “ The social problem of the future we considered to be, how to unite the greatest individual liberty of action, with a common ownership in the raw material of the globe, and an equal participation of all
[p. xxxiii]in the benefits of combined labour." But he recognised that Socialism demanded from the working classes a higher type of character than they possessed at the time. So long as their political beliefs continued to be actuated by their individual interests, rather than by the welfare of the State, he held that they were not fitted for Socialism. He looked to education as the chief means of raising them to take a wider view of politics than their private interests ; and once they had been educated up to that higher level, he believed that Socialism would be both practicable and desirable. In this view he never wavered throughout his life. But his opinion differed greatly at different periods of his life as to when this desirable consummation would be reached. At one time, sharing in the extravagant hopes that were widely entertained as to the result of free education, he appeared to think that the goal was but a short distance off. Towards the end of his life, he formed a less sanguine estimate of the time that must elapse before the working classes were ripe for the change.1
It is not my purpose to attempt a criticism of Mill's various works in the light of modern knowledge. They no longer occupy, of course, the position of unassailable authority which they once occupied. But they have stood the test of time with extraordinary success. When we remember that the last half-century has witnessed an advance in knowledge, on almost every side, of unparalleled rapidity ; when we reflect that the scientific books published to-day are usually out-of-date in two or three years' time, we have reason to be astonished, not that Mill's writings have been to some extent superseded by later works, but that they still retain so large—so justifiably large—a portion of authority as they actually do. Every one of them, at the time of its first publication, was an immense advance on anything that had gone
[p. xxxiv]before. Many of them were held to be dangerously Radical in their expressions of opinion. An indication of the abhorrence in which he was held in some quarters may still be gathered by turning over the numerous pages devoted to his works in the Catalogue of Printed Books at the British Museum. One of these pages is headed by the entry “ Mill (John Stuart) ; see Antichrist.”
Probably the most serious deficiency in Mill’s ideas, is due to the fact that they belong to the pre-evolutionary era. Nowadays the doctrine of organic evolution enters into all our thought, and colours our conclusions on almost every subject. We regard humanity as being on the move, not as a stationary manifestation of the immutable order of the Universe. We take a dynamical rather than a statical view of society. On such matters, Mill occupies a position half-way between modern views and the views of the early Utilitarians. The Utilitarians lived in an age when biology was in its infancy, and when its conclusions had neither the certainty nor the importance that would entitle them to be taken into consideration. They assumed that all men were born alike, and that education alone could mould them into any desired form. Bentham thought that the Panopticon would soon root out dishonesty. James Mill argued that the means by which the “grand objects of desire may be attained, depend almost wholly upon the political machine.” And correlated with this one-sided notion of humanity, was their belief that political economy covered the whole sphere of government, that deductions from the principle of the “Greatest happiness of the greatest number” sufficed to provide universal guidance in all political concerns. John Mill made a great advance on his predecessors. Though still believing that differences of character were traceable to differences of environment, to a far greater extent than would now be admitted, he yet perceived that this was not the whole story. He was not so convinced as his predecessors had been, that the millennium would attend upon suitable manipulations of the political machine. He saw that other considerations
[p. xxxv], besides those of political economy, were necessary to govern the activity of the State. But he had no conception, such as we now have, of a positive antithesis between the interests of the individual and the interests of the race. His philosophy did not extend beyond the attempt to promote the happiness of the population by means of supplying an apt environment. It did not occur to him to inquire what might be the effects of such action upon the fundamental qualities of the race. He perceived, as Malthus had perceived, that most social evils are consequent upon the existence of a population whose needs were greater than could be met by the existing fertility of the earth's surface. He also perceived, as Malthus also had perceived, that for every increment of productive capacity there was a further increase of population, so that the expansion of industry effected no alteration in the permanent ratio between supply and demand. And he inferred, as Malthus had inferred, that restriction of the population was the panacea for the majority of human evils.
In the days when these propositions were first enunciated, the discovery of “Natural Selection” had not been made. Men were in the deepest ignorance of Nature's ways in all that appertained to inheritance or the philosophy of life. A corner, at least, of the veil has now been lifted; and behold! we find Nature taking bypaths which earlier philosophers never suspected for an instant, and which vitiate, or at any rate call for careful modifications of Malthus' conclusion. For it is now known that individuals born into the world are not all of one pattern, but of extreme diversity in physical, mental, and moral development. It is known that newly-born individuals diverge from the average type, sometimes for the better, but often for the worse. So long as there are many more individuals born than there can possibly be room for (which is the normal condition), many have to die out. It is obvious that the victims are mainly the weak and imperfect. It is the strong, those most suited to the world into which they are born, who survive
[p. xxxvi]and carry on the race to future generations. So that Nature exercises a selective action upon new-born individuals, casting off the weak and maintaining only the fittest. Nature works, that is to say, not by producing a quantity of individuals, any one of whom is as fitted to survive as any other, but by producing a larger quantity of mixed individuals than is required, and then picking out the most robust among them. Here then is a serious flaw in Malthus' argument. By limiting the number of births, you doubtless diminish the number of deaths and the sum of contemporary human misery; but, to the precise extent that you are successful in preventing the wastage of human life, you are interfering with Nature's operation of weeding out the unfit. Unfavourable variations, instead of being destroyed on their appearance, are maintained and perpetuated, leading ultimately to race-degeneracy and extinction. In short, the Malthusian philosophy is a philosophy of the individual, and runs counter to the wider philosophy of the race. I need not pursue the argument further. The modern view would not advocate going back to the days of heedless multiplication, bringing with it so much misery to the unfortunate individuals who are in process of elimination. It would, of course, have to admit the principle of selection; but would take that selection out of the cruel hands of Nature, and pass it into human control. By taking measures to prevent multiplication of the unfit, it is believed that limitation of the population may be achieved, without incurring the disastrous effects of degeneracy. It is even suggested that positive improvements in the physique of the race might thus be ensured.
I have no wish to discuss the plausibility of these doctrines. I merely wish to mention some of the new factors brought into view by the rise of biology, to indicate the limitations of Mill's political philosophy. They constitute, in reality, no criticism on Mill himself, but only on the knowledge of the age of which he was the leading spirit. The economic era, in which Mill flourished, is giving place to a biologic era. What, it is
[p. xxxvii]asked, is the use of devoting so much effort to improving individuals by means of the environment, when such improvements perish with them and have to be wrought all over again upon their children ? Is it not better to lay out the time and money in the operations of selective breeding, when the improvements that are attained are inherited and become the inalienable property of the race for all time ? And back comes the rejoinder from objectors : Are you certain that your biology is correct and complete ? Are you aware that your attempt to control human evolution is to take upon yourself a responsibility greater by far than any that has ever before confronted mankind ? Have you reflected that, where the consequences of your action for evil or for good will be so infinitely mighty, any flaw in your fundamental principles may entail consequences proportionately disastrous ?
It is in these directions that political philosophy is widening out. If Mill lived too early to give us the benefit of his direct advice upon them, he nevertheless has cleared the way indirectly for their solution. And this he has done in two ways : negatively, by helping to dissipate the cloud of ignorance and prejudice in which so many political problems in his time were steeped ; positively, by setting a standard of freedom of thought, and earnest seeking after truth, that must for long continue to inspire succeeding thinkers. It may be possible to find philosophers of more powerful genius than Mill ; it may be possible to find philosophers of more steady emotional balance ; but I believe it would be altogether impossible to name any philosopher who has had the welfare of humanity so deeply at heart, or who has laid himself out so consistently and unsparingly in labouring for the progress of his fellow-men.
HUGH ELLIOT.
Notes
- 1Queen's Square Place.
- 2The cat.
- 3"The English Utilitarians," by Leslie Stephen, vol. iii. p. 3.
- 1“John Stuart Mill,” by A. Bain, p. 163.
- 1“Journals of Caroline Fox,” quoted by W. L. Courtney in his “Life of John Stuart Mill.”
- 1Bowring's “ Life of Bentham,” in Bentham's Works.
- 1“John Stuart Mill,” p. 18.
- 1“Autobiography,” p. 117.
- 2“John Stuart Mill,” p. 142.
- 1“John Stuart Mill,” by A. Bain, p. 149.
- 2Or, as Bain characteristically puts it in his biography of James Mill: “ His [John's] nervous energy was so completely absorbed in his unremitted intellectual application, as to be unavailable for establishing the co-ordinations of muscular dexterity.”
- 1James Mill, on the other hand, was strongly opposed to Socialism. In a letter to Lord Brougham, dated 3rd September 1832, at the height of the Reform struggle, he wrote with reference to Socialism : " These opinions, if they were to spread, would be the subversion of civilised society ; worse than the overwhelming deluge of Huns and Tartars."
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.






















