To James Lorimer, · on Plural Voting.
Dear Sir,—Allow me to thank you for your very interesting treatise, which…
To James Lorimer,
on Plural Voting.
Blackheath, 3rd March 1859.
1859
—
Aetat. 52.
Dear Sir,—Allow me to thank you for your very interesting treatise,1 which, having been absent, I have only just had an opportunity of reading. We agree to a considerable extent in our practical views, particularly in the important point (almost new, I think, in the theory of representation) that the proper safeguard against the undue preponderance of a class more numerous than all others taken together, is not the exclusion of anybody, but the graduation of influence proportionally to just claims. Between some influence and more influence the ratio is finite and appreciable, but between some and none at all it is mathematically infinite. No one could without voluntary degradation admit that he ought to be counted for nothing, though every reasonable person is eager to admit that there are persons entitled to be counted for more than himself.
But while we agree thus far, we differ very much on other points. I would not give any one a plurality of votes in consequence of any merely social superiority, and your general principle of making the representative assembly an exact reflection of existing inequalities of weight and position seems to me liable to very strong objections, with which, as I shall probably write something on the matter, I will not trouble you here.
I would also include women in the ultimate universal suffrage that you contemplate—which as far as I can collect from a note in your book you would not do. I think your principles break down altogether if you allow of any exceptions among persons sui juris.
Notes
- 1[“Equal Representation.”]
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.
