Letter 105
Dear Sir,—Having been absent from home…
3rd March 1859.
Dear Sir,—Having been absent from home, it is only within the last few days that I have had an opportunity of reading and studying your book—which I have done with no ordinary feelings. You appear to me to have exactly, and for the first time, solved the difficulty of popular representation—and by doing so, to have raised up the cloud of gloom and uncertainty which hung over the futurity of representative government and therefore of civilisation. That you are right in theory I never could have doubted, and as to practice, having begun with a great natural distrust of what seemed a very complicated set of arrangements, I ended by being convinced that the plan is workable, and effectually guarded or guardable against fraud. In the details I have as yet found only one point which, it seems to me, might be improved, and that is so minor a one as hardly to be worth mentioning. You propose that (assuming the quota to be 2000) the first 2000 votes a candidate obtains at the place for which he stands should be counted for his return, and his name struck out of all subsequent voting papers. Should it not be the last 2000 rather than the first ? Otherwise there is a premium on hanging back from the poll ; the later voters having more power than the earlier ones, inasmuch as after the attainment of their first object their second votes also are counted.
Excuse my offering this very small criticism on a scheme for which I shall henceforth be a zealous apostle. I am as sanguine as you are yourself respecting the moral and political effects of it, which would far transcend anything that is apparent at first sight. A thing so complete will not, however, be attained at one step, and it is therefore mortifying that the principle of representation of universities is not in some way recognised (however imperfectly it might be realised) by the ministerial Reform Bill.
Allow me to add that while I so entirely concur both in the principles of your book and in its practical proposals, I have also the good fortune to agree with most even of your
[p. 216]1859
—
Aetat. 52.
incidental remarks on things in general.—I am, yours with great respect,
J. S. Mill.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

