To Thomas Carlyle.
I have allowed myself to be paralysed more than I should during the last month or two by…
To Thomas Carlyle.
India House, 11th and 12th April 1833.
My dear Carlyle,—I write to you again a letter which I could wish were better worth having—really an apology for a letter. Your last, which you called so, deserved a better name. I would write if it were only to thank you for having a better opinion of me than I have of myself. It is useless discussing which is right; time will disclose that, though I do not think that my nature is one of the many things into which you see “some ten years farther” than I do. At all events I will not, if I can help it, give way to gloom and morbid despondency, of which I have had a large share in my short life, and to which I have been indebted for all the most valuable of such insight as I have into the most important matters, neither will this return of it be without similar fruits, as I hope and almost believe; nevertheless I will and must, though it leaves me little enough of energy, master it, or it will surely master me. Whenever it has come to me it has always lasted many months, and has gone off in most cases very gradually.
I have allowed myself to be paralysed more than I should during the last month or two by these gloomy feelings, though I have had intervals of comparative brightness; but they were short. I have therefore a poor
[p. 43]1833
—
Aetat. 26.
account to render of work done. Tait has not yet published that paper on Junius Redivivus, but in the meantime I have written another on the same subject for Fox1 (a much better one, as I think), which has appeared in the April number, and should have been sent if I had got it in time for Fraser's parcel ; you shall have it by the first opportunity. With this exception I have written little and read less ; but this shall have an end.
You will have received long before this time by Fraser two tracts of mine of very different kinds, a political or rather ethico-political one on Church and Corporation Property, and the one I told you of long ago, in Fox's periodical, on Poetry and Art. That last you promised me a careful examination and criticism of : I need it much, for I have a growing feeling that I have not got quite into the heart of that mystery, and I want you to show me how. If you do not teach me you will do what is better, put me in the way of finding out. But I begin to see a not very far distant boundary to all I am qualified to accomplish in this particular line of speculation. I have also sent the Trial of the Saint-Simonians, a letter from d'Eichthal, and one from Duveyrier. I have lately heard again both from and of the latter. He is now writing in the Revue des Deux Mondes, which he says is the first in France in the department of literature and art, and to which a number of their most celebrated writers, so far as any of their writers can be called celebrated, contribute. He writes to me, "je me lance décidément dans le drame et le théâtre. Je fais une grande pièce, mais comme cela ne fait pas vivre pour le moment, je cherche à gagner mon pain courrant par quelques articles de journaux. J'ai quelqu' espoir d'avoir à la Revue des Deux Mondes où j'ai beaucoup d'amis, de rediger la chronique de quinzaine politique et théâtrale. En attendant je n'entends plus parler de d'Eichthal, qui est toujours en Italie." What I have heard of Duveyrier is that, being condemned to a year's imprisonment along with Enfantin and Chevalier, he applied through his relations for a pardon from the Government, and obtained
[p. 44]1833
—
Aetat. 26.
it, I suppose by declaring his intention of quitting the Father of Humanity. This I heard from a friend of his. Such part of the Saint-Simonians as remain faithful, or at least a large body of them headed by Barrault, have, as I find from the French newspapers, set out for the East (Constantinople, I was told, was their first destination) pour chercher la Femme libre. This seems greater madness than I had imputed to them. It is among the inmates of a harem that they expect to find a woman capable of laying down, or as they say, revealing the new moral law which is to regulate the relations between the sexes ! It will be lucky for them if the search is attended with no disagreeable personal consequences to them except only that of not finding. The Saint-Simonians have done so much good that one regrets they were not capable of doing more. One of the seceding members writes of them in the Revue Encyclopédique that the Saint-Simonian Society is the only spiritual fruit of the Revolution of 1830. It is literally so ; the excessive levity and barrenness of the French mind has never been so strikingly displayed ; there are such numbers of talkers and writers so full of noise and fury, keeping it up for years and years, and not one new thought, new to them, I mean, has been struck out by all the collection since they began attending to these matters, except only those which the Saint-Simonians have set afloat among them. It is no wonder that minds so little productive as the French should run wild with an interesting truth when they have had it impressed upon them. Saint-Simon really for a Frenchman was a great man. Enfantin likewise pourrait bien être aussi une espèce de grand homme, as Voltaire said ; the others were probably mere redactors and amplifiers of their thoughts, a talent as common in France as the power of original thinking seems to be rare. If you can get hold of it at Edinburgh, read a novel called “Arthur Coningsby,” by John Sterling ; he is one of the men who would most interest you among those here, and his book will interest you ; I should much like to know what it looks like when seen from your point of view.
[p. 45]1833
—
Aetat. 26.
Though I am sick of politics myself, I do not despair of improvement that way; you hear the cackle of the noisy geese who surround the building, I see a little of what is going on inside. I can perfectly sympathise in Bonaparte's contempt of the government of bavards; talking is one thing and doing another: but while every corner of the land has sent forth its noisy blockhead to talk, overhead I am near enough to see the real men of work, and of head for work, who are quietly getting the working part of the machine into their hands, and will be masters of it as far as anybody can be with that meddling and ignorant assembly lawfully empowered to be their masters. After that let even one man come, who with honesty, and intellect to appreciate these working men, has the power of leading a mob—no rare combination formerly, though a very rare one now; and there will be as good a government as there can be until there shall be a better people. It is a real satisfaction to me to know, and in some cases to have even been able somewhat to help on, several men who are now gaining by dint of real honesty and capacity a considerable and increasing influence, though not an externally visible one, over the underworkings of our government. Some of these are, as I am convinced, among the very fittest persons in the country to have that influence, fit or not as they may be in a greater or less degree for still higher purposes. A chacun selon sa capacité is far enough from being realised, to be sure, but the real deviation, great as it is, falls far short of the apparent. It is much more in their apparent than in their real power, that such men as Brougham and Althorp are exalted above their proper station.
Fonblanque, you see, goes on hammering at the politics of the day, for better, for worse; I have seen less than usual of him lately. The public mind is coming round to him; the popularity of the Reform Ministry will soon be at as low an ebb as that of the poor Patriot King. How long is this dreary work to last, before a man appears? Mrs. Austin is at present laid up with the prevalent influenza, a sort of cold accompanied with fever; she and
[p. 46]1833
—
Aetat. 26.
her husband seem to have almost resolved to emigrate into Germany this autumn. The Bullers are here ; Charles has gone the Western Circuit this spring, and got some briefs ; I have increasing hopes of his steadiness and power of work. I have little to tell of any one else whom you know here. Is De Quincey still in Edinburgh ? do you ever see him ? and what do you think of him ? Your criticism on Miss Martineau is, I think, just ; she reduces the laissez faire system to absurdity as far as the principle goes, by merely carrying it out to all its consequences. In the meantime that principle, like other negative ones, has work to do yet, work namely of a destroying kind, and I am glad to think it has strength left to finish that, after which it must soon expire ; peace be with its ashes when it does expire, for I doubt much if it will reach the resurrection. I wish you could see something I have written lately about Bentham and Benthamism—but you can't. My best thanks to Mrs. Carlyle for the few words of kindness she added to your last letter. I keep so little note of time that I know not whether I have redeemed my promise of writing after a less interval than usual—but you will write soon.—Yours ever faithfully,
J. S. Mill.
Notes
- 1[W. J. Fox, editor of the Monthly Repository.]
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.




