To Alexander Bain.
. . . I am your debtor for an interesting letter, dated as long ago as 8th September.
To Alexander Bain.
St. Véran, 15th October 1859.
. . . I am your debtor for an interesting letter, dated as long ago as 8th September. I am afraid I shall not be able to repay you in kind. You have probably seen before this time what I have written about your book.1 I am glad to see by the advertisement that Reeve has put it at the head of the number. What you say of the notices in the Athenæum and press gave me pleasure. I saw accidentally part of another, apparently favourable, and likely to be useful, in the Guardian. The single paragraph in the Westminster was shabby, but I hope Grote persists in his intention of reviewing you there when he has finished with Plato—who seems to take him a length of time only to be warranted by using the opportunity to speak out very plainly on the great subjects—a thing I rather wish than expect he will be found to have done; though the perfect impunity of the bold things in the “Liberty” ought to give him the courage of one qui bene est ausus vana contemnere. Have you seen any of the recent reviews of the “Liberty” ? That in the Dublin University Magazine, for instance, and the series of letters in the English Churchman? People are beginning to find out that the doctrines of the book are more opposed to their old opinions and feelings than
[p. 225]they at first saw, and are taking the alarm accordingly and rallying for a fight. But they have in general dealt candidly with me, and not too violently. As was to be expected, they claim for Christian morality all the things which I say are not in it, which is just what I wanted to provoke them to do. The article in the National Review on my writings generally is worth reading. It seems to be by Martineau, and I am obliged to him for it, since it is favourable to the utmost extent consistent with the writer's opinions, and decidedly tends to increase rather than diminish the influence which he says is already so great. I really had no idea of being so influential a person as my critics tell me I am. But being thought to have influence is the surest way of obtaining it really. The arguments of the reviewer on the contested points you will, I think, agree with me in considering to be very easily answerable. . . .
1859
—
Aetat. 53.
Notes
- 1[Mill's review of Bain's psychological works in the Edinburgh.]
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

