To T. Cliffe Leslie, · on an article written by him on Income Tax Reform.
this morning. It is an able, and will be a useful paper…
To T. Cliffe Leslie,
on an article written by him on Income Tax Reform.
St. Véran, 20th December 1861.
Dear Sir,—I received the proof of your article only
this morning. It is an able, and will be a useful paper, and puts some points in a new and forcible way, though I differ from it on several matters of detail and some of principle. The chief of these is the question of exempting savings, on which your arguments have not shaken my conviction. The strongest of them is that a tax on expenditure is unjust to those professional persons who are obliged to spend more than they gain in the early years of their career. It is impossible to answer this argument completely. But the force of it is much weakened by
[p. 249]several considerations. In the first place, what the professional man is obliged to expend in maintaining himself before his earnings come in, is capital, and as such would, on my plan, have been previously relieved from the portion of income tax it now pays. The not taxing the capital when it was formed, is an equivalent for taxing it, when it is laid out. In the second place, the tax he pays on this outlay would, if savings were untaxed, be entirely refunded to him by the exemption he would enjoy in the process of replacing the outlay from his subsequent earnings. (This entirely refutes the last sentence of the first paragraph of page 114.) The inconvenience is thus limited to that of making an advance. That is doubtless a special disadvantage. But some inequalities are unavoidable in all modes of taxation; and even your plan would not relieve him from the whole of it, since taxing him on only two-thirds of his income would not come up to the requirements of the case of one whose income is less than half of his present expenditure.
1861
—
Aetat. 55.
. . . . . .
I think you overstate the case against taxes on articles of general consumption. You say that a duke's family does not consume very much more “of certain things” than an artisan's or a clerk's. Not nearly so much in proportion to their means; but much more absolutely, since they pay for all that is consumed by their servants and dependants. . . .
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

