To Thomas Carlyle.

J. S. MillThomas Carlyle

I wrote a short letter to you intending to send it by your brother when he went to…

5 · VII · 1833LondonPrinted pp. 52–55

To Thomas Carlyle.

1833
—
Aetat. 27.

My dear Carlyle,—

I wrote a short letter to you intending to send it by your brother when he went to Craigenputtock; but he did not find time to call on me again, and I, having very foolishly mislaid his address, did not find out his place of abode till some hours after he had left town. As the letter was very short and had little in it, I cancelled it, and determined to write a longer and better, which however I have not set about till now. In the meantime I have received your letter, which was welcome on many accounts, on none more than because it recognises in express words what has always been tacitly recognised but seldom spoken or written about by either of us, the negative part of the relation between us, the fact that we still differ in many of our opinions, perhaps, as you say (though of this I am not sure), throughout the range of a “half-universe.” I certainly shall not hesitate to show you “the length and breadth of my dissent.” But the truth is, I had persuaded myself for a long time that the difference was next to nothing; was such as counted for little in my estimation at least, being rather in some few of our speculative premises than in any of our practical conclusions. When I came to review my opinions and ask myself, after a considerable period of fresh thought and fresh experience, the deliberate question, which at some periods assumes a more serious and solemn aspect than at others, what I believed? what were my convictions? I found that they were, and for the present could not but be, more materially divergent from yours than I had for a time believed. As soon as I felt quite sure of this I told you so; and though I wrote as if in a sceptical and unsettled state of mind, the very fact that I wrote at all about it proved that I had come into a more settled state. I think that I have obtained something like a firm footing, and additional rather than new light; I can hardly say that I have changed any of my opinions, but I seem to

[p. 53]

myself to know more, from increased observation of other people, and increased experience of my own feelings. All which is thus acquired must be clear gain ; it is increased knowledge of the only valuable kind, knowledge of Realities ; and it must be for want of intellect or for want of will, if, with additional ground to build upon, I cannot raise my edifice of Thought to a greater height, and so look round and see more of Truth than I could see before. But of all these things we shall both write and speak hereafter. Concerning my journey to Craigenputtock, all I can at present say is, that if I go not thither I shall go nowhere else. However, it will not at all events be in August, for in that month my father will be absent, and it is inconvenient for both of us to be away from the India House at the same time. It cannot be till he return. I had the pleasure of an hour's conversation with Dr. Carlyle on his passing through London, and was glad to learn that he is to be an inmate of Craigenputtock all this summer and autumn. My occupations for some time back have been rather internal than external ; I have not been working much, but much has been working in me. I have written little, partly because I was better employed in obtaining whereof to write than in writing, partly also because of press of business at the India House, and of certain temporary domestic occupations in my father's house. I have completed scarcely anything but a poor, flimsy, short paper on that book of Alison's, which I undertook in an evil hour, when the subject was as remote as possible from those which were occupying my thoughts and feelings at the time, and which I accordingly performed exceedingly ill, and was obliged to cancel the part which had cost me most labour ; what is left (it is not worth your perusal), will appear in the Monthly Repository. Short as the whole is, it has been divided into two parts, of which one has appeared ; it had been better to reserve the whole for another number. I shall in future never write on any subject which my mind is not full of when I begin to write, unless the occasion is such that it is better the thing were ill done than not at all, that being the alternative

1833

—
Aetat. 27.

[p. 54]

1833
—
Aetat. 27.

. What you say of that paper of mine on Poetry and Art is exactly what I think respecting it myself. I do not think it contains anything erroneous, but I feel that it is far from going to the bottom of the subject, or even very deep into it; I think I see somewhat further into it now, and shall perhaps understand it in time. I think I mentioned to you that I have carried the investigation (rightly or wrongly, as it may be) one step further in a paper (being a review of a new poem) which I wrote for the Examiner: it proved too long for Fonblanque, and it is to appear in Tait, after such additions and alterations as I see it absolutely requires, and which I have not yet found time to give it. You say you wish that you could help me in this matter; you can and do help me in all such matters, not by logical definition, which, as I think I have said or written before, I agree with you in thinking not to be your peculiar walk of usefulness; but in suggesting deep and pregnant thoughts which might never have occurred to me, but which I am quite able, when I have them, to subject to all needful logical manipulation. This brings to my mind that I have never explained what I meant when, writing once before in this strain, I called you a poet and artist. I conceive that most of the highest truths are, to persons endowed by nature in certain ways which I think I could state, intuitive; that is, they need neither explanation nor proof, but if not known before are assented to as soon as stated. Now, it appears to me that the poet or artist is conversant chiefly with such truths, and that his office in respect to truth is to declare them and to make them impressive. This, however, supposes that the reader, hearer, or spectator is a person of the kind to whom those truths are intuitive. Such will, of course, receive them at once, and will lay them to heart in proportion to the impressiveness with which the artist delivers and embodies them. But the other and more numerous kind of people will consider them as nothing but dreaming or madness: and the more so, certainly, the more powerful the artist, as an artist. The same person may be poet and logician, but he cannot be both in the same

[p. 55]

composition : and as heroes have been frustrated of glory “ carent quia vate sacro,” so I think the vates himself has often been misunderstood and successfully cried down for want of a Logician in Ordinary, to supply a logical commentary on his intuitive truths. The artist’s is the highest part, for by him alone is real knowledge of such truths conveyed ; but it is possible to convince him who never could know the intuitive truths that they are not inconsistent with anything he does know, that they are even very probable, and that he may have faith in them when higher natures than his own affirm that they are truths. He may then build on them and act on them, or at least act nothing contradictory to them. Now, this humbler part is, I think, that which is most suitable to my faculties as a man of speculation. I am not in the least a poet in any sense, but I can do homage to poetry. I can to a very considerable extent feel it and understand it, and can make others who are my inferiors understand it in proportion to the measure of their capacity. I believe that such a person is more wanted than even the poet himself ; that there are more persons living who approximate to the latter character than to the former. I do not think myself at all fit for the one ; I do for the other : your walk I conceive to be the higher. Now one thing not useless to do would be to exemplify this difference itself ; to make those who are not poets understand that poetry is higher than logic, and that the union of the two is philosophy. I shall write out my thoughts more at length somewhere and somewhen, probably soon.—Yours faithfully,

1833
—
Aetat. 27.

J. S. Mill.

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 106 of the 1910 edition (printed page 52), showing letter 14.
Printed page 52 · scan leaf 106 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 107 of the 1910 edition (printed page 53), showing letter 14.
Printed page 53 · scan leaf 107 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 108 of the 1910 edition (printed page 54), showing letter 14.
Printed page 54 · scan leaf 108 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 109 of the 1910 edition (printed page 55), showing letter 14.
Printed page 55 · scan leaf 109 of 378Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter 14 of 165 · printed pp. 52–55 · scan leaf 106 of 378

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot, 1910, pp. 52–55.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationJ. S. Mill to Thomas Carlyle, 5 July 1833, “To Thomas Carlyle.”. In The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot (London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910), pp. 52–55. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/14/.

BibTeX@incollection{mill-letters-vol1-1910-letter-0014,
  author    = {J. S. Mill},
  title     = {To Thomas Carlyle., 5 July 1833},
  booktitle = {The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I},
  publisher = {London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910},
  year      = {1910},
  pages     = {52--55},
  note      = {Edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot. Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/14/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/14/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.