To the Right Hon. Joseph Napier, · on Miracles.

John Stuart MillJoseph Napier

I have at your suggestion re-read the second chapter of the second part of the “Analogy…

27 · I · 1863Blackheath ParkPrinted pp. 281–282

To the Right Hon. Joseph Napier,
on Miracles.

Dear Sir,—

I have at your suggestion re-read the second chapter of the second part of the “Analogy,” and the result is somewhat different from what you seemed to expect. I am afraid I must admit that Butler's authority is against me, and that he rather overlooked, or did not admit, the distinction which I endeavoured to draw between two kinds of improbability, improbability before the fact and improbability of an alleged fact. For though, as you say, he does not deny that there is a certain small antecedent presumption against a miracle, he looks upon this as being exactly the same sort of presumption which there is against any common event (of the conditions of which we have no special antecedent knowledge) before it has happened. Now, in my view it is a totally different sort of presumption —one which constitutes, as far as it goes, a ground of disbelief

[p. 282]

1863
—
Aetat. 56.

, which the other and universal presumption does not even in the smallest degree. In proof of this, let there be a million of tickets in some repository, numbered and placed indiscriminately. Of these I take out one ; the antecedent presumption against its being No. 72 is a million to one ; but when I have selected a ticket and it is affirmed to be No. 72, the antecedent presumption does not render this in the smallest degree incredible, because, instead of its being unlikely that an event with a million to one against it would happen it was certain that such an event would happen, and it is certain that such an event did happen when I took out the ticket, whether it was No. 72 or not.

Now (without further purpose distinguishing miracles from any other kind of extraordinary event) it seems to me clear that against any extraordinary event there exists not a slight addition to this entirely unimportant kind of probability, but an improbability generically different from it, and Butler surely must have thought so. . . .

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 343 of the 1910 edition (printed page 281), showing letter 146.
Printed page 281 · scan leaf 343 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 344 of the 1910 edition (printed page 282), showing letter 146.
Printed page 282 · scan leaf 344 of 378Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter 146 of 165 · printed pp. 281–282 · scan leaf 343 of 378

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot, 1910, pp. 281–282.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationJohn Stuart Mill to Joseph Napier, 27 January 1863, “To the Right Hon. Joseph Napier, · on Miracles.”. In The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot (London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910), pp. 281–282. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/146/.

BibTeX@incollection{mill-letters-vol1-1910-letter-0146,
  author    = {John Stuart Mill},
  title     = {To the Right Hon. Joseph Napier, · on Miracles., 27 January 1863},
  booktitle = {The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I},
  publisher = {London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910},
  year      = {1910},
  pages     = {281--282},
  note      = {Edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot. Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/146/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/146/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.