To Thomas Carlyle.
and expected, and in one sense waited for, a considerable time…
To Thomas Carlyle.
Kensington, 22nd December 1833.
My dear Carlyle,—Your letter had been hoped for
and expected, and in one sense waited for, a considerable time, for I had various matters of interest to write to you about, but as I hoped for a letter so soon I delayed writing till I could make my letter answer yours.
One of those matters is the affair of the Examiner, of which you have heard somewhat from Hayward. It is in difficulties, and those of so serious a kind that if something had not been done or attempted immediately to save it, there was danger of its stopping altogether. The cause is melancholy enough, being less the circumstances of the paper, though it is not prosperous, than those of Fonblanque himself, who, like his father before him, has wanted firmness to restrain his expenses within his means. Since he enlarged the paper in January 1831 it has yielded him little; it allows him nominally £500 a year; reckoning that in addition to its other expenses it has during these three years lost on the average £6 a week, which coming out of his £500 reduced it to below £200. He, meantime, has been living at a rate most needlessly expensive, and is at last so completely drained, and his credit I should think so completely exhausted, that he can go on no longer. Strange that a man who writes so feelingly and powerfully on this same weakness should so act; but not at all strange, only melancholy, that one who so acts, possessing intellect, should so write. If his difficulties do not ruin the paper it is in no danger. For means of retrenchment present themselves to the extent of £8 or £9 a week, by discharging Chadwick, whose work Fonblanque takes upon himself in addition to his own, and by cheaper arrangements for
[p. 82]1833
—
Aetat. 27.
printing and paper, which, however, depend upon first paying off an arrear to his printer and stationer. £1000 would do all this and start him fair with £500 a year and an improving property; for advertisements, the great source of profit to a paper, have, as you must have observed with pleasure, multiplied exceedingly in the Examiner since the reduction of the duty. The £1000 it were to be wished that some one person of the right disposition should have advanced, become thereby proprietor in place of Fonblanque, whose personal circumstances would then have ceased to compromise the paper, and who would, of course, have been retained as editor. This I would myself have preferred to do, were not my position with regard to the India House, which hampers my freedom of action in a thousand ways, but which shall not hamper it always, in this case an insuperable obstacle. What has been attempted is to raise the money in subscriptions of £10 each from a hundred different persons, each of whom is to receive the paper gratis for ten years. Sixty promises have been obtained, the remaining forty are still to seek: as many as twenty more are, I think, as good as certain—but less than the whole hundred will not do, for the debts on the paper amount to £780, and money to the extent of the remainder will then be wanted to start it fair, or perhaps (for I know not) to keep poor Fonblanque out of the King's Bench. I am doing all I can to interest people in the matter, and should have written to you among the first, had I not known that you could do little if anything in the way either of subscribing or procuring subscriptions. I think we shall succeed, but it will require a vigorous effort. The sale of the Examiner does not much exceed 3000 copies. This is, as you say, a scandalous symptom, yet there are many causes that contribute to it besides the scandalous ones that first suggest themselves. Of course it can only expect buyers (readers are quite another matter) from Radicals; and of them the more vulgar sort find as much Radicalism in the papers, of a more direct and popular kind, with greater breadth, as the painters say: for Fonblanque's genius, fine as it is, goes all into the details, not into the general
[p. 83]1833
—
Aetat. 27.
mode of treating a subject; he does not go straight to the main point, dwell upon that and make that tell, dropping all little side views, like the Times, which with material of no intrinsic value whatever writes powerfully for popular effect, as Fonblanque might do with his powers, though scarcely with his turn of mind. Then Fonblanque's allusions, expressions, style, all the garb of his thoughts, is intelligible, or at least impressive, only to persons of literary, one might say almost classical, education, and most of them are not Radicals—not to mention that such as do not take a daily paper, require in a weekly one a better abstract of news. That I hope will now, in some degree, be mended. Then the more moderate Radicals are revolted by the tone of hatred in which the paper is written. This feeling extends to many who would have no objection to, but would applaud, the utterance of the bitterest truths, but do not like a perpetual carping at little things, honestly indeed, yet often unfairly, and making no personal allowances, sometimes misstating altogether the kind of blame which is deserved, and meting it out in unequal measure to different people, so as to give an appearance of spleen and personal antipathy to individuals—especially to some of the Ministers, and among them, most perhaps to some of those who deserve it rather less than the others. In all this there is much truth; on the other hand, much also is to be said for Fonblanque, but on the whole not enough to acquit him entirely. So he has really no partisans at all, and loses by almost all his excellences and by his faults too. At the very time when he was offending the moderate Radicals by the nature of his attacks on the Ministry, he was losing at the rate of a hundred subscribers every week for some time by resisting the anti-police furor. Still, the position of the paper will be a good one if this money can be raised, and raised I hope it will be.
I have another piece of news to tell you: the principal Radicals in Parliament, and many of those out of it, have a scheme for starting a new quarterly review, and are exerting themselves so much for it that they will probably
[p. 84]1833
—
Aetat. 27.
succeed in setting it going.1 The first promoters of it were Roebuck, Buller, and I; and we shall probably be the surest and most regular contributors, though there will be abundant others. All the educated Radicals to whom the thing has been mentioned enter into it with a degree of warmth unusual with them, and offer both pecuniary and literary assistance. There is but one exception, and that one I regret to say is Grote, who has gradually sunk into a state always too congenial to him, of thinking that no good is to be done, and who therefore will certainly never do any—at most no harm, and scarcely that, for it is harm to discourage others. A bookseller is willing to take the risk for two years, provided editorship and writers are found for that period; in order to do so the rich Radicals, Strutt, Warburton, Sir W. Molesworth, the Marshalls of Leeds, and others, are going to raise money of the necessary amount among themselves and their friends in shares of £25 or £50, the same person being allowed to take any number. The plan (Roebuck's and mine, to which all have at once assented) is to drop altogether every kind of lying, the lie of pretending that all the articles are reviews when more than half of them are not, and the lie of pretending that all the articles proceed from a corps who jointly entertain all the opinions expressed. There is to be no we, but each writer is to have a signature, which he may avow or not as he pleases, but which (unless there be special reasons to constitute an exception) is to be the same for all his articles, thus making him individually responsible, and allowing his opinions to derive what light they can from one another, the editor answering only for adequate literary merit, and a general tendency not in contradiction to the objects of the publication. They would, I believe, make me editor if I would take it, but I cannot; hampered again! But this time it is of little consequence, for I hope they will have Mr. Fox, who will be quite as fit: if they will not have him, there are other candidates not unfit though not so fit. If this scheme goes on, I hope you will write
[p. 85]1833
—
Aetat. 27.
for the review, or at least in it. As an organ of utterance it will be at least more congenial to you than Fraser's Magazine. It is true the prejudices of our utilitarians are at least as strong against some of your writings as those of any other persons whatever, though the individual signature would smooth many difficulties. But such an article as that on Johnson they would have delighted in; that on Ebenezer Elliott and various others of yours would have suited them perfectly. In fact, I hardly know one of your opinions, as often as you do not feel yourself called upon to make a direct attack upon themselves, which they would have any difficulty in getting on with; and I expect no difficulty in getting a passport for any of mine, which, except in mere metaphysics, are quite as unlike theirs as yours are: what revolts them is the combination of opinions new and often strange to them, with a manner to them equally new and still more strange, and which prevents them not only from understanding your meaning but from desiring to understand it. I have never found one of them who, after taking the trouble to read enough of your writings to understand anything of your drift, did not recognise in them much more of what he deemed good than of what he deemed bad; it is true I have found few who would take that trouble, and some of those few would not have done so if they had not had faith (derived from my testimony) that it was worth while. I tell you this to let you know how the land lies. There is nothing in what I have said that needs be any obstacle to your writing for this review—it simply shows under what conditions either of subject or else of manner your writings will be acceptable to it. To me your manner, being the natural clothing or rather skin of your thoughts, is (whenever I understand those) all that it should be; so, however, is Plato's, whom, however, I would not counsel to preach at St. Paul's in good Attic Greek; of course I am exaggerating for the purpose of illustration. Here is a letter neither menschlich nor geistlich but wholly dinglich; you will be, I think, not more than a week
[p. 86]1833
—
Aetat. 27.
without another letter, there is so much of the two former kind to be said. I have not answered your letter, as you see. As for your letters, they are never, I think, more menschlich than when they are geistlich, nor more geistlich than when menschlich.—Yours affectionately,
J. S. Mill.
Notes
- 1[It was started as the London Review in 1835.]
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.





