To Thomas Carlyle.

J. S. MillThomas Carlyle

My dear Carlyle,—Your little note dated the 24th was evidently written before you…

12 · I · 1834KensingtonPrinted pp. 87–93

To Thomas Carlyle.

1834
—
Aetat. 27.

My dear Carlyle,—Your little note dated the 24th was evidently written before you received my letter written I forget when, but which I fear lost the first week's post. I am therefore still expecting an answer to that letter, but shall not wait for it, mindful that I still owe you an answer to your last long letter, and a fuller answer, too, than can be given in any moderate space. I feel that letter a kind of call upon me to a more complete unfolding to you of my opinions and ways of thinking than I have ever yet made; which, however, cannot be all accomplished at once, but must be gradual. In the very fact that there has not been that full explanation, and that I feel moved to it now, you may see that there has taken place a great change in my character, and one of which you will wholly approve; a change, not from any kind of insincerity, but to a far higher kind of sincerity than belonged to me before. This change has been progressive, and had barely begun to take place when you were in London two years ago. I was then, and had been for one year, in an intermediate state, a state of reaction from logical-utilitarian narrowness of the very narrowest kind, out of which after much unhappiness and inward struggling I had emerged, and had taken temporary refuge in its extreme opposite. My first state had been one of intense philosophic intolerance, not arising from the scornfulness of the heart but from the onesidedness of the understanding, seeing nothing myself but the distorted image, thrown back from many most oblique and twisted reflectors, of one side only of the truth.

[p. 88]

1834
—
Aetat. 27.

I felt towards all who saw any other side, not indeed a feeling of disdain, for that never was in my character, but the very utmost excess of intellectual vilipending. At that time I was thought to outrer the doctrines of utilitarianism even by those who now consider me a lost sheep who has strayed from the flock and been laid hold of by the wolves. That was not wonderful, because even in the narrowest of my then associates, they being older men, their ratiocinative and nicely concatenated dreams were at some point or other, and in some degree or other, corrected and limited by their experience of actual realities, while I, a schoolboy fresh from the logic school, had never conversed with a reality, never seen one, knew not what manner of thing it was, had only spun, first other people's and then my own deductions from assumed premises. Now when I had got out of this state, and saw that my premises were mere generalisations of some of the innumerable aspects of Reality, and that far from being the most important ones ; and when I had tried to go all round every object which I surveyed, and to place myself at all points of view, so as to have the best chance of seeing all sides, I think it is scarcely surprising that for a time I became catholic and tolerant in an extreme degree, and thought onesidedness almost the one great evil in human affairs, seeing it was the evil which had been the bane of my own teachers, and was also that of those who were warring against my teachers. I never indeed was tolerant of aught but earnest belief ; but I saw, or seemed to see, so much of good and of truth in the positive part of the most opposite opinions and practices, could they but be divested of their exclusive pretensions, that I scarcely felt myself called upon to deny anything but denial itself. I never made strongly prominent my differences with any sincere, truth-loving person ; but held communion with him through our points of agreement, endeavoured in the first place to appropriate to myself whatever was positive in him, and, if he gave me any encouragement, brought before him also whatever of positive might be in me, which he till then had not. A character most unlike yours, of a quite lower kind,

[p. 89]

1834
—
Aetat. 27.

and which if I had not outgrown, and speedily too, there could have been little worth in me. Do you remember a paper I wrote in an early number of Tait, reviewing a book by a Mr. Lewes (a man of considerable worth, of whom I shall have something more to say yet). That paper paints exactly the state of my mind and feelings at that time. It was the truest paper I had ever written, for it was the most completely an outgrowth of my own mind and character; not that what is there taught was the best I even then had to teach, nor perhaps did I even think it so, but it contained what was uppermost in me at that time, and differed from most also that I knew in having emanated from me, not, with more or less perfect assimilation, merely worked itself into me. Now, from this my intellectual history, in relating which I have faith that I have not presumed too much upon your interest in me, you will easily see why it is that we two have so rarely canvassed together, or even mentioned to each other, our differences. I never, or rarely, felt myself called upon to come into collision with any one, except those to whom I felt myself altogether superior, and with whom, if I had any intellectual communion, it was not for the sake of learning but of teaching. I have not till lately, and very gradually, found out that this is not honest; that although I have not positively, I have negatively, done much to give to you and to others a false opinion of me, though the deliberation with which you form your opinions, always waiting for sufficient grounds, has, I think, protected you from forming an actually false opinion of me, and I have only to accuse myself of not having afforded you sufficient means of forming the true. Whether if you knew me thoroughly I should stand higher, or lower, either in your esteem or in your affection, I know not; in some things you seem to think me further from you than I am, in others perhaps I am further from you than you know. On the whole I think if all were told I should stand lower; but there cannot fail, any way, to be much which we shall mutually not only respect but greatly prize in each other; and after all, this, as you and I both know, is altogether of secondary

[p. 90]

1834
—
Aetat. 27.

importance, the first being, that we, and all persons and all things, should be seen truly, and as they are. Our differences are indeed of the first importance, and to you must appear of infinite importance, though for reasons which you will feel the force of, they do not, in my feeling, throw me to so great a distance from you as they perhaps will in yours. The first and principal of these differences is that I have only what appears to you much the same thing as, or even worse than, no God at all, namely, a merely probable God. By probable I do not mean as you sometimes do, in the sense of the Jesuits, that which has weighty authorities in its favour. I mean that the existence of a Creator is not to me a matter of faith or of intuition ; and as a proposition to be proved by evidence, it is but a hypothesis, the proofs of which, as you I know agree with me, do not amount to absolute certainty. As this is my condition in spite of the strongest wish to believe, I fear it is hopeless ; the unspeakable good it would be to me to have a faith like yours, I mean as firm as yours, on that, to you, fundamental point, I am as strongly conscious of when life is a happiness to me, as when it is, what it has been for long periods now past by, a burthen. But I know that neither you nor any one else can be of any use to me in this, and I content myself with doing no ill by never propagating my uncertainties. The reason why I think I shall never alter in this matter is, that none of the ordinary difficulties, as they are called, as the origin of evil, and such like, are any serious obstacles to me ; it is not that the logical understanding invading the province of another faculty will not let that other higher faculty do its office—there is wanting something positive in me which exists in others ; whether that something be, as sceptics say, an acquired association, or as you say, a natural faculty : so you see I am nearly as proper an object of your pity as Cavaignac ; nevertheless I do not feel myself so, having, as I have, other supports, which the want of that one cannot take away. With respect to the immortality of the soul I see no reason to believe that it perishes, nor sufficient ground for complete assurance that

[p. 91]

1834
—
Aetat. 27.

it survives; but if it does there is every reason to think that it continues in another state such as it has made itself here, and no further affected by the change than it would be by any equally great event during its sojourn on earth, were such possible; consequently in all we do here we are working in our hereafter as well as our “now.” Now, were you aware that I was in such a state of uncertainty on these main points? I am almost sure that you were not much mistaken in the matter, but yet were not quite certain that you knew.

Another of our differences is, that I am still, and am likely to remain, a utilitarian, though not one of “the people called utilitarians”; indeed, having scarcely one of my secondary premises in common with them; nor a utilitarian at all, unless in quite another sense from what perhaps any one except myself understands by the word. It would take a whole letter to make it quite clear to you what I mean, and I feel perfectly that I have stated the difference between us in a manner and in terms which give no just idea of what it really is, and that every explanation I shall hereafter make will show that difference to be less than the words I have used seem to import. One of the explanations I have to give, I partly indicate by saying, as I do most fully, that I entirely recognise with you the “infinite nature of Deity.” Yet, by this too, if unexplained, I should convey an idea of as much greater an agreement with you than the truth warrants, as I do in the other case of a less agreement. This also must wait till another time for a fuller development. You will see, partly, with what an immense number and variety of explanations my utilitarianism must be taken, and that those explanations affect its essence, not merely its accidental forms, when I tell you that on the very point on which you express your belief so kindly and with so much ménagement, and appeal to my future self, and promise not to be angry if I differ from you “even with vehemence,” I agree and have long agreed with you, even in the most decided and vehement manner. I have never, at least since I had any convictions of my own, belonged to the benevolentiary, soup-kitchen

[p. 92]

1834
—
Aetat. 27.

school. Though I hold the good of the species (or rather of its separate units) to be the ultimate end (which is the alpha and omega of my utilitarianism) I believe with the fullest belief that this end can in no other way be forwarded but by the means you speak of, namely, by each taking for his exclusive aim the development of what is best in himself. I qualify or explain this doctrine no otherwise than as you yourself do, since you hold that every human creature has an appointed task to perform, which task he is to know and find out for himself; this can only be by discovering in what manner such faculties as he possesses or can acquire may produce most good in the world; meaning by the world a larger or a smaller part of it, as may happen. Thus you think it a part of your duty, of your work, to address yourself, through the press, to the “species” at large. Further than that I do not go, perhaps even less far, and when once I have written down my belief and sent it forth in such manner as happens or seems to be the most effectual within my reach, I harass myself as little as you do with any thought about the consequences, being like yourself perfectly satisfied that what I have done, if done in the spirit of my own creed, will “prove in reality all and the utmost that I was capable of doing” for mankind.

And now do not “take it ill” if I say how much it surprised me that you should think it necessary to say you would not “take it ill” if I differed from you. I never for an instant suspected that you would take ill any difference of opinion while you continue fully assured that the dissentient is sincere, earnest, and truth-loving; and you never allow me to be under a moment’s fear that you are unassured of that in my case. Grieved you might be at what you might deem my errors, but that feeling you could not mean to disavow, nor would it be any pleasure to me, but the contrary, if you could. In your recent letters you have several times expressed surprise at opinions and feelings of mine which you did not expect, and which you have said proved to you how little you yet know me; and which in truth did show how small a part of my character I had yet

[p. 93]

1834
—
Aetat. 27.

shown to you, so much smaller a part than I was aware of : truly I begin to think that instead of being, as you thought I was, the most self-conscious person living, I am much less self-conscious now (whatever I was once) than almost anybody. But what most shows how little I had afforded you an insight into me, is that the fact of my having recently read the New Testament, and what I wrote to you of the impressions it had made upon me, should have formed, as it seems to have done, an era in your opinion and feeling concerning me. In my own history it is no era ; it has made no new impression, only strengthened the best of the old ; I have for years had the very same idea of Christ, and the same unbounded reverence for him as now ; it was because of this reverence that I sought a more perfect acquaintance with the records of his life, that indeed gave new life to the reverence, which in any case was becoming or was closely allied with all that was becoming a living principle in my character.

Here is a very long letter, yet how little it says of all that is to be said ! However, you see that you are likely to know much more of me hereafter than you have known hitherto. Make my kind remembrances to Mrs. Carlyle, and believe me faithfully yours,

J. S. Mill.

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 141 of the 1910 edition (printed page 87), showing letter 23.
Printed page 87 · scan leaf 141 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 142 of the 1910 edition (printed page 88), showing letter 23.
Printed page 88 · scan leaf 142 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 143 of the 1910 edition (printed page 89), showing letter 23.
Printed page 89 · scan leaf 143 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 144 of the 1910 edition (printed page 90), showing letter 23.
Printed page 90 · scan leaf 144 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 145 of the 1910 edition (printed page 91), showing letter 23.
Printed page 91 · scan leaf 145 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 146 of the 1910 edition (printed page 92), showing letter 23.
Printed page 92 · scan leaf 146 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 147 of the 1910 edition (printed page 93), showing letter 23.
Printed page 93 · scan leaf 147 of 378Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter 23 of 165 · printed pp. 87–93 · scan leaf 141 of 378

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot, 1910, pp. 87–93.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationJ. S. Mill to Thomas Carlyle, 12 January 1834, “To Thomas Carlyle.”. In The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot (London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910), pp. 87–93. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/23/.

BibTeX@incollection{mill-letters-vol1-1910-letter-0023,
  author    = {J. S. Mill},
  title     = {To Thomas Carlyle., 12 January 1834},
  booktitle = {The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I},
  publisher = {London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910},
  year      = {1910},
  pages     = {87--93},
  note      = {Edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot. Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/23/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/23/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.