To E. Lytton Bulwer (afterwards Lord Lytton)
My dear Sir,—I have just returned from an absence of nearly four months on the Continent…
To E. Lytton Bulwer (afterwards Lord Lytton)
India House, 23rd November 1836.
1836
—
Aetat. 30.
My dear Sir,—I have just returned from an absence of nearly four months on the Continent, rendered necessary by an obstinate though in no way alarming indisposition, which has lasted for more than a twelvemonth, and which, together with another far more melancholy circumstance, had obliged me during that period to put aside all occupations which could be dispensed with, and among other things to leave my friend Molesworth's review1 very much to shift for itself. Now, when I am sufficiently recovered to be able to revert to my former interests and pursuits, one of the things I am most concerned about is how the greatest value and efficiency may be given to that review—and I am sure that I speak the sentiments of all connected with it when I say that nothing would conduce so much to either end as your hearty co-operation, if we could be so fortunate as to obtain it. I have since my return read your article on Sir Thomas Browne with an admiration I have seldom felt for any English writings on such subjects. I did not know at the time that it was yours, and could not conceive what new accession had come to the Edinburgh Review. I first thought it might possibly be Macaulay's, but as I read on I felt it to be far too good for him. It has
[p. 104]An illustration is printed here, on scan leaf 158.
JAMES MILL
[p. 103]1836
—
Aetat. 30.
much of the same brilliancy, but not his affected and antithetical style, and above all a perception of truth, which he never seems to have, and a genuine love of the True and the Beautiful, the absence of which in him is the reason why, among his thousands of clever things and brilliant things, there are so few true things and hardly one which is the whole truth and nothing but the truth. I could not help saying to myself, who would look for these qualities in the Edinburgh Review ? How the readers of that review must be puzzled and bewildered by a writer who actually takes decided views, who is positively in earnest, and is capable of downright admiration and even enthusiasm ! I am sure your writing must be lost upon them ; they are not people who can recognise or care about truth ; your beautiful things will be to them merely clever things and amusing things comme tant d'autres. Among us, you would at least find both writers and readers who are in earnest. I grant that you, and such writing as yours, would be nearly as much out of place in our review as it has been, as in the Edinburgh ; but not, as I hope it will hereafter be. As good may be drawn out of evil—the event which has deprived the world of the man of the greatest philosophical genius it possessed,1 and the review (if such little interests may be spoken of by the side of great ones) of its most powerful writer, and the only one to whose opinions the editors were obliged to defer—that same event has made it far easier to do that in the hope of which alone I allowed myself to become connected with the review, namely, to soften the harder and sterner features of its Radicalism and Utilitarianism, both which in the form in which they originally appeared in the Westminster were part of the inheritance of the eighteenth century. The review ought to represent not Radicalism but Neo-Radicalism, a Radicalism which is not democracy, not a bigoted adherence to any forms of government or to one kind of institutions, and which is only to be called Radicalism inasmuch as it does not palter nor compromise with evils, but cuts at their roots—and a utilitarianism which takes into
[p. 104]1836
—
Aetat. 30.
account the whole of human nature; not the ratiocinative faculty only, but the utilitarianism which never makes a peculiar figure as such, nor would ever constitute its followers a sect or school—which fraternises with all who hold the same axiomata media (as Bacon has it), whether their just principle is the same or not—and which holds in the highest reverence all which the vulgar notion of utilitarianism represents them to despise—which holds feeling at least as valuable as thought, and Poetry not only on a par with, but the necessary condition of, any true and comprehensive Philosophy. I know I am writing very loosely and expressing myself very ill, but you will understand me, and as I have, through Molesworth's confidence in me, complete power over that review whenever I choose to exercise it, I hope you will believe that if the review has hitherto been too much in the old style of Radical-utilitarianism with which you cannot possibly sympathise very strongly (nor I either), it is because the only persons who could be depended upon as writers, were those whose writings would not tend to give it any other tone. My object will now be to draw together a body of writers resembling the old school of Radicals only in being on the movement side, in philosophy, morality, and art as well as in politics and socialities—and to keep the remnant of the old school (it is dying out) in their proper place, by letting them write only about the things which they understand. But this attempt must fail unless those who could assist it will. Why should you not write for us a series of articles on the old English writers, similar to that on Browne? They would be quite invaluable to us; we have not among our habitual writers any who could be trusted to write on such subjects—those who would have enough of the requisite feelings and talents, have not the requisite reading. We have now, since the junction with the Westminster, readers enough to make it worth while; and readers who are in earnest; readers by whom what you write would be taken au sérieux and not as a mere play of intellect and fancy. Your writing for us need not hinder you from writing for the Edinburgh also if you like it; but I am sure you must often
[p. 105]feel that not to be a fitting vehicle for anything not of a stationary character either in literature or politics—passe encore if you could hope by your writings to modify the character of the work itself—but that is hopeless. Now among us you could.
1836
—
Aetat. 30.
Do pray think of it, and tell me the result of your thought. The time is evidently approaching when the Radicals will once more be a distinct party, and when people will look to the Review as their organ, and much will depend upon its being an organ which represents the best part of them, and not the narrowest and most repulsive.—Ever yours faithfully.
J. S. Mill.
Notes
- 1[The London and Westminster Review.]
- 1[James Mill.]
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.




