To E. Lytton Bulwer
I have read your article with great eagerness and delight…
To E. Lytton Bulwer
Wednesday [1837].
1837
—
Aetat. 31.
My dear Sir,—
I have read your article1 with great eagerness and delight; it is such as I expected from you, and if we could have one such article in every number I should have no misgivings respecting our critical reputation. I have hardly found a sentence which has not my heartiest concurrence, except perhaps some part of what you say of Shelley, and there I am not sure that there is any difference, for all that you say to his disparagement I allow to be true, though not, I think, the whole truth. It seems to me that much, though not most, of Shelley's poetry is full of the truest passion; and it seems to me hardly fair to put Shelley in the same genus as Gray, when the imagery of the one, however redundant and occasionally far-fetched, is always true to nature, and that of the other, as you say yourself, drawn from books and false; the one, the exuberant outpouring of a seething fancy, the other elaborately studied and artificial.
But perhaps you think all this as well as I; if so, and only if so, would not some little addition or qualification give a truer impression?
I had not time the other evening to tell you how much I am delighted with “Athens”; the book is so good that very few people will see how good.—Ever yours,
J. S. Mill.
Notes
- 1[On “The Works of Thomas Gray,” published in the London and Westminster Review for July 1837.]
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.
