To John Sterling.
. . . Touching your question to me…
To John Sterling.
East India House, 4th November 1839.
1839
—
Aetat. 33.
. . . Touching your question to me, whether I think that we know a sufficient number of laws of particular phenomena to be able to mount up to the laws of the whole system of which they are a part—if you mean, to such laws as that which Coleridge ascribes to Heraclitus and Giordano Bruno, the essential polarity of all power—I do not think that the time is come for such wide generalisations, though I do not consider the attainment of them hopeless at some future period. I am afraid that the only principles which I should at present recognise as laws of all phenomena, are some of those which for that very reason are classed by Kant as laws of our perceptive faculties only—subjective, not objective—as, for instance, the subjection of all phenomena to the laws of time and space. But it would require a good deal of explanation before we could make ourselves understood by each other on this matter, and for my part, I dare say, I may have something to learn on this subject from the German philosophers when I have time to read them. You may think it presumptuous in a man to be finishing a treatise on logic and not to have made up his mind finally on these great matters. But mine professes to be a logic of experience only, and to throw no further light upon the existence of truths not experimental, than is thrown by showing to what extent reasoning from experience will carry us. Above all, mine is a logic of the indicative mood alone—the logic of the imperative, in which the major premiss says not is but ought, I do not meddle with.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.
