To John Sterling,

J. S. MillJohn Sterling

You must have wondered at not hearing from me sooner; and not without good reason.

X · 1831India HousePrinted pp. 3–19

To John Sterling,

shortly after he had departed for the West Indies, to undertake the management of a sugar estate in St. Vincent. Mill was now at the height of his reaction against Benthamism.

1831
—
Aetat. 25.

Dear Sterling,—

You must have wondered at not hearing from me sooner; and not without good reason. It is true that I have not heard from you non plus, so that we seem to have been equally neglectful of one another. But (1) very probably a letter from you is now on its way here. (2) Your silence ought only to be counted from your arrival, and mine from your setting out. (3) I have had only my ordinary occupations, while you have had all the trouble of settling in a new place, of commencing an entirely new mode of life and kind of occupation, and when this was just done, you were turned out by a vile hurricane and obliged to begin the whole thing over again. (4) A letter from home is still more precious than even the most interesting letter from abroad. (5) Though you have not written to me, you have to others, and I have seen part of what you wrote: now when a man is a great way off, his letter to one of his friends may be taken mutatis mutandis as a letter to all, but that cannot be said of their letters to him. You see I have stated the case against myself as strongly as I can, in order to leave you nothing to add to it. As I have no excuse to make which will not leave my case worse than it is already, I can only make you the best reparation in my power by writing you an exceedingly long letter this time. I suppose that it is right to

[p. 4]

1831
—
Aetat. 25.

suppose that you must desire en premier lieu to hear about public affairs, now when they are in so ticklish a state: but really I can tell you little more than you will learn from the newspapers. The rejection of the Reform Bill by the large majority of 41 in the House of Lords, has given an immense impulse to the mouvement in this country. All chance that the Bill when passed should prove a healing measure is at an end. The House of Lords is now as much detested as ever the House of Commons was. Nothing less than the creation of from 60 to 100 Liberal Peers, to change the character of the House, can now give it any chance of remaining in existence. It is said that they flinch, and will pass the Bill without any new creation, but that will not now save them. They will come into collision with the Reformed House on some other point, and will certainly go to the wall. You may consider the fate of the Church as sealed. Only two Bishops voted for the Bill; about five more stayed away, the rest voted against it. The hierarchy being thus, as a body, hostile to it, while the temporal Peers were almost equally divided, the first brunt of public indignation has fallen upon the Prelacy. Every voice is raised against allowing them to continue in the House of Lords, and if I do not express my conviction that they will be excluded from it before this day five years, it is only because I doubt whether the House itself will last so long. I cannot say I regret either the approaching downfall of the Peers or that of the Church. I certainly think it desirable that there should be a Conservative branch of the legislature; and that there should be a national clergy or clerisy, like that of which Coleridge traces the outline in his work on Church and State. If therefore I thought that the present Peerage and Clergy would ever consent to become the peerage of a government constituted on anti-jobbing principles and the clergy of a non-sectarian church, I should pray for their continuance. But they never will. Can a Peerage so ignorant as ours is proved to be by its recent vote, of the spirit of the age and the feelings of the people, ever be able to fulfil with judgment the ends of a checking body, which are,

[p. 5]

to yield to all steady impulses of opinion which are likely to be permanent, and to resist those which are in their nature temporary and changeable ? And as for the clergy, who does not see that they are mainly divisible into two great categories, the worldly-minded and the sectarians ? I know that you will not agree with me, but I think that Coleridge would, in thinking that a national clergy ought to be so constituted as to include all who are capable of producing a beneficial effect on their age and country as teachers of the knowledge which fits people to perform their duties and exercise their rights, and as exhorters to the right performance and exercise of them ; now I contend that such persons are to be found among all denominations of Christians, nay, even among those who are not Christians at all ; provided (which I deem an essential condition in the present stage of human progressiveness) they abstain from either directly attacking, or indirectly undermining Christianity, and even adopt, (as far as without hypocrisy they can) those means of addressing the feelings and the conscience to which a connection with Christianity has given potency. An infidel who attempts to subvert or weaken the belief of mankind in Christianity ought not, in my opinion, to form a part of the national clerisy ; not because he may not be performing a conscientious duty in so doing, but because it is to me a proof that he misunderstands the wants and tendencies of his age, and that the effect of his exertions would probably be to make men worse instead of better by shaking the only firm convictions and feelings of duty which they have, without having even a remote chance of furnishing them with any effectual substitute. Accordingly, in France, where Christianity has lost its hold on men's minds, my reasoning would not apply. There, I believe that a Christian would be positively less fit than a St. Simonian (for example) to form part of a national church. These, then, are my ideas of a church establishment ; ideas which I shall promulgate to the public in some shape or other when I shall see a good opportunity for their being attended to. But I feel certain that no church, not

1831
—
Aetat. 25.

[p. 6]

1831
—
Aetat. 25.

founded on this comprehensive principle, can or ought to stand. I believe that if any clan of Christians, Socinians for example, or even Deists, or Atheists, were excluded, you could not select your clergy from the remainder of mankind without including persons less fit in every respect than some whom you would exclude. Besides, you would then retain that encouragement to hypocrisy, that holding out of worldly motives first to the adoption and next to the obstinate retention of particular creeds, which has disgusted so many high-minded men with church establishments ; which has made them to be considered as obstacles to improvement, as the creation of a class with an interest adverse to the progressiveness of the species. In the present age of transition, everything must be subordinate to freedom of inquiry : if your opinions, or mine, are right, they will in time be unanimously adopted by the instructed classes, and then it will be time to found the national creed upon the assumption of their truth. But what chance is there that the Church, as at present constituted, will consent to undergo, even by the most insensible steps, this transformation ? and that, too, at a time when insensible steps will not suffice. If they would, the recent elevation of Whately to the Archbishopric of Dublin, and of Maltby to the Bishopric of Chichester, would greatly encourage me ; the former, because I think him one of the fittest men in the country to hold a high station in a national church such as I conceive it should be, the latter for the very reason which makes others disapprove of it, his want of orthodoxy. But all this might do while the people were attached to the Church. At present they are hostile to it ; hostile, consequently, to all church establishments, because they know of none better than this ; and they would be more likely to accept an entirely new one than one which they considered to be a transformation of this. Why is it almost the natural course of things in politics that destruction must precede renovation ? It is because reform is delayed till the whole attachment of the public to the entire of the institution is gone, and then they feel a distrust of anything which looks like patching up the old edifice. So

[p. 7]

I believe it to be both with Church and State at this moment. You have no doubt seen in the English papers the speeches at public meetings, and the various resolutions which have been agreed to. These are generally very strong, but they were, in every case, the weakest which there was the least chance that the people would have adopted. Almost everywhere, if any person came forward and proposed stronger resolutions, they were carried by acclamation, much to the dissatisfaction of those who called the meeting and prepared the proceedings. I am convinced that we are indebted for the preservation of tranquillity solely to the organisation of the people in political unions. All the other unions look to the Birmingham one, and that looks to its half-dozen leaders, who consequently act under a most intense consciousness of moral responsibility, and are very careful neither to do nor say anything without the most careful deliberation. I conversed the other day with a Warwickshire magistrate, who told me that the meeting of 150,000 men a few days previous would have done any thing without exception which their leaders might have proposed. They would have passed any resolutions, marched to any place, or burnt any man's house. The agricultural people are as determined as the manufacturers. The West is as exalté as the North. Colonel Napier made a speech at the Devizes meeting the other day for the express purpose (as I hear) of letting the men in the North perceive that the West is ready to join in any popular movement if necessary; and since that speech (which the leaders in vain attempted to prevent him from delivering) he has received numbers of letters from all parts of the country saying that they all look to him as their leader, and are ready to place themselves under his command. If the ministers flinch or the Peers remain obstinate, I am firmly convinced that in six months a national convention, chosen by universal suffrage, will be sitting in London. Should this happen, I have not made up my mind what will be best to do: I incline to think it would be best to lie by and let the tempest blow over, if one could but get a

1831
—
Aetat. 25.

[p. 8]

1831
—
Aetat. 25.

shilling a day to live upon meanwhile ; for until the whole of the existing institutions of society are levelled with the ground, there will be nothing for a wise man to do which the most pig-headed fool cannot do much better than he. A Turgot even could not do in the present state of England what Turgot himself failed of doing in France—mend the old system. If it goes all at once, let us wait till it is gone ; if it goes piece by piece, why, let the blockheads who will compose the first Parliament after the Bill passes do what a blockhead can do, viz. overthrow, and the ground will be cleared and the passion of destruction sated, and a coalition prepared between the wisest Radicals and the wisest anti-Radicals, between all the wiser men who agree in their general views and differ only in their estimate of the present condition of this country. You will perhaps think from this long, prosing, rambling talk about politics that they occupy much of my attention ; but, in fact, I am myself often surprised how little I really care about them. The time is not yet come when a calm and impartial person can intermeddle with advantage in the questions and contests of the day. I never write in the Examiner now except on France, which nobody else that I know of seems to know anything about ; and now and then on some insulated question of political economy. The only thing which I can usefully do at present, and which I am doing more and more every day, is to work out principles ; which are of use for all times, though to be applied cautiously and circumspectly to any : principles of morals, government, law, education, above all self-education. I am here much more in my element ; the only thing that I believe I am really fit for is the investigation of abstract truth, and the more abstract the better. If there is any science which I am capable of promoting, I think it is the science of science itself, the science of investigation—of method. I once heard Maurice say (and, like many things which have dropped from him, its truth did not strike me at first, but it has been a source of endless reflection since) that almost all differences of opinion when analysed were differences of method. But if so, he who can throw most

[p. 9]

1831
—
Aetat. 25.

light on the subject of method will do most to forward that alliance among the most advanced intellects and characters of the age, which is the only definite object I ever have in literature or philosophy, so far as I have any general object at all. Argal, I have put down upon paper a great many of my ideas on logic, and shall in time bring forth a treatise; but whether it will see the light until the Treaty of Westphalia is signed at the close of another cycle of reformation and antagonism no one can tell, except Messrs. Drummond, M‘Niel, Irving, and others, who profess the hidden key to the Interpretation of the Prophecies. I have just put the finishing hand to my part of a work on Political Economy, which Graham and I are writing jointly; our object is to clear up some points which have been left doubtful, to correct some which we consider to be wrong, and to show what the science is and how it should be studied. I have written five essays—four on detached questions and one on the science itself. Graham is to write five more on the same subjects; we are then to compare notes, throw our ideas into a common stock, talk over all disputed points till we agree (which, between us two, we know by experience to be by no means an indefinite postponement), and then one of us is to write a book out of the materials. Graham is to add a sixth essay on a very important part of the subject which is above my reach, and which I am only to criticise when it is done. I am now resting upon my oars. Yesterday I completed my task, and, having reached a sort of landing-place (vide the Friend), I have asked myself what recreation I could offer myself by way of reward for past and encouragement to future exertions; and nothing better has yet occurred to me than writing to you. The next thing I shall do will be to complete my speculations on Logic: very likely I shall not get to the end of the subject yet, viewed as I understand it; but I shall at least gather in another harvest of ideas, and then let the ground lie fallow a while longer. After this I shall probably put down upon paper a vast quantity of miscellaneous ideas which are wrought out to a certain extent in my head, but which it would be quite

[p. 10]

1831
—
Aetat. 25.

premature to publish for a long while to come. I have nothing in view for the public just now, except (when the Reform Bill shall have passed) to resume my series of papers headed “The Spirit of the Age,” and to write an article or two for the Jurist (now about to be revived) on some abstract questions of general legislation. When I shall have completed all this, then, if the East India Company is abolished, and funded property confiscated, I shall perhaps scrape together the means of paying my passage to St. Vincent’s and see whether you will employ me to teach your niggers political economy. I take it for granted that if a Reformed Parliament should begin taking measures for the emancipation of the slaves, you will all join the United States, who, being lovers of liberty, will, I trust, go to war with Republican England to restore you and the other colonists to the inalienable rights of freemen.

I have done nothing in this letter but talk to you about the world in general and about myself. I must now talk to you about other people, and particularly about several new acquaintances of mine that I had not made or had only just begun to make when you left this white world. First of all, I went this summer to the lakes, where I saw much splendid scenery, and also saw a great deal both of Wordsworth and Southey; and I must tell you what I think of them both. In the case of Wordsworth, I was particularly struck by several things. One was, the extensive range of his thoughts and the largeness and expansiveness of his feelings. This does not appear in his writings, especially his poetry, where the contemplative part of his mind is the only part of it that appears; and one would be tempted to infer from the peculiar character of his poetry that real life and the active pursuits of men (except of farmers and other country people) did not interest him. The fact, however, is that these very subjects occupy the greater part of his thoughts, and he talks on no subject more instructively than on states of society and forms of government. Those who best know him seem to be most impressed with the catholic character of his ability. I have been told that Lockhart has said of him that he would have been an

[p. 11]

1831
—
Aetat. 25

admirable country attorney. Now a man who could have been either Wordsworth or a country attorney could certainly have been anything else which circumstances had led him to desire to be. The next thing that struck me was the extreme comprehensiveness and philosophic spirit which is in him. By these expressions I mean the direct antithesis of what the Germans most expressively call one-sidedness. Wordsworth seems always to know the pros and the cons of every question; and when you think he strikes the balance wrong it is only because you think he estimates erroneously some matter of fact. Hence all my differences with him, or with any other philosophic Tory, would be differences of matter-of-fact or detail, while my differences with the Radicals and Utilitarians are differences of principle; for these see generally only one side of the subject, and in order to convince them you must put some entirely new idea into their heads, whereas Wordsworth has all the ideas there already, and you have only to discuss with him the “how much,” the more or less of weight which is to be attached to a certain cause or effect as compared with others: thus the difference with him turns upon a question of varying or fluctuating quantities, where what is plus in one age or country is minus in another, and the whole question is one of observation and testimony, and of the value of particular articles of evidence. I need hardly say to you that if one’s own conclusions and his were at variance on every question which a minister or a Parliament could to-morrow be called upon to solve, his is nevertheless the mind with which one would be really in communion; our principles would be the same, and we should be like two travellers pursuing the same course on the opposite banks of a river. Then when you get Wordsworth on the subjects which are peculiarly his, such as the theory of his own art, if it be proper to call poetry an art (that is, if art is to be defined as the expression or embodying in words or forms of the highest and most refined parts of nature), no one can converse with him without feeling that he has advanced that great subject beyond any other man, being

[p. 12]

1831
—
Aetat. 25.

probably the first person who ever combined, with such eminent success in the practice of the art, such high powers of generalisation and habits of meditation on its principles. Besides all this, he seems to me the best talker I ever heard (and I have heard several first-rate ones) ; and there is a benignity and kindliness about his whole demeanour which confirms what his poetry would lead one to expect, along with a perfect simplicity of character which is delightful in any one, but most of all in a person of first-rate intellect. You see I am somewhat enthusiastic on the subject of Wordsworth, having found him still more admirable and delightful a person on a nearer view than I had figured to myself from his writings, which is so seldom the case that it is impossible to see it without having one's faith in man greatly increased and being made greatly happier in consequence. I also was very much pleased with Wordsworth's family— at least, the female part of it. I am convinced that the proper place to see him is in his own kingdom—I call the whole of that mountain region his kingdom, as it will certainly be as much thought of hereafter by the people of Natchitoches or of Swan River, as Mœnalus and the Cephissus, or Baiæ and Soracte by ourselves, and this from the fortuitous circumstance that he was born there and lived there. I believe it was not there that you were acquainted with him, and therefore I am not telling you an old story in talking about the little palace or pavilion which he occupies in this poetic region, and which is, perhaps, the most delightful residence in point of situation in the whole country. The different views from it are a sort of abstract or abridgment of the whole Westmoreland side of the mountains, and every spot visible from it has been immortalised in his poems. I was much pleased with the universality of his relish for all good poetry, however dissimilar to his own, and with the freedom and unaffected simplicity with which every person about him seemed to be in the habit of discussing and attacking any passage or poem in his own works which did not please them. I also saw a great deal of Southey, who is a very different

[p. 13]

1831
—
Aetat. 25.

kind of man, very inferior to Wordsworth in the higher powers of intellect, and entirely destitute of his philosophic spirit, but a remarkably pleasing and likeable man. I never could understand him till lately; that is, I never could reconcile the tone of such of his writings as I had read with what his friends said of him: I could only get rid of the notion of his being insincere by supposing him to be extremely fretful and irritable; but when I came to read his “Colloquies,” in which he has put forth much more than in any other work, of the natural man, as distinguished from the writer aiming at a particular effect, I found there a kind of connecting link between the two parts of his character, and formed very much the same notion of him which I now have after seeing and conversing with him. He seems to me to be a man of gentle feelings and bitter opinions. His opinions make him think a great many things abominable which are not so; and against which, accordingly, he thinks it would be right and suitable to the fitness of things, to express great indignation; but if he really feels this indignation, it is only by a voluntary act of the imagination that he conjures it up, by representing the thing to his own mind in colours suited to that passion: now, when he knows an individual and feels disposed to like him, although that individual may be placed in one of the condemned categories, he does not conjure up this phantom and feels therefore no principle of repugnance, nor excites any. No one can hold a greater number of the opinions, and few have more of the qualities which he condemns, than some whom he has known intimately and befriended for many years; at the same time he would discuss their faults and weaknesses or vices with the greatest possible freedom in talking about them. It seems to me that Southey is altogether out of place in the existing order of society; his attachment to old institutions, and his condemnation of those who administer them, cut him off from sympathy and communion with both halves of mankind. Had he lived before Radicalism and infidelity became prevalent, he would have been the steady advocate of

[p. 14]

1831
—
Aetat. 25.

the moral and physical improvement of the poorer classes, and denouncer of the selfishness and supineness of those who ought to have considered the welfare of those classes as confided to their care. Possibly the essential one-sidedness of his mind might then have rendered him a democrat; but now the evils which he expects from increase of the power wielded by the democratic spirit as it now is, have rendered him an aristocrat in principle without inducing him to make the slightest compromise with aristocratic vices and weaknesses. Consequently, he is not liked by the Tories, while the Whigs and Radicals abhor him. And after all, a man cannot complain of being misinterpreted who always puts the worst interpretation upon the words and deeds of other people. As far as I have yet seen, speculative Toryism and practical Toryism are direct contraries. Practical Toryism simply means, being in and availing yourself of your comfortable position inside the vehicle without minding the poor devils who are freezing outside. To be a Tory means either to be a place-hunter and jobber, or else to think that (as Turgot expressed it) “tout va bien, parce que tout va bien pour eux”; to be one “qui ayant leur lit bien fait, ne veulent pas qu’on le remue.” Such Toryism is essentially incompatible with any large and generous aspirations; nor could any one who had such aspirations ever have any power of realising them under our system, whatever might be his attachment to the forms of the Constitution, because the inert mass of our sluggish and enervated higher classes can be moved by nothing that does not come from without, and with a vengeance; they cannot be led, but must be driven; the clamour of the “fierce democracy” can alone stir their lazy and feeble minds, and awaken them from the sleep of indifference. What can you do when there is no faith in human improvement, and every glaring, disgusting evil which they cannot deny is set down as the inevitable price we pay for social order, and irremediable by human efforts? “It is all very true, but what can we do?” is the ready answer of everybody who can possibly avoid doing something; and you can say nothing in reply but

[p. 15]

1831
—
Aetat. 26.

this, “Then, if you can do nothing for that society which has hitherto made nobody the happier unless it be yourselves, the rest of mankind must try what they can do to improve their own lot without your assistance, and then, perhaps, you may not like their manner of proceeding.” If there were but a few dozens of persons safe (whom you and I could select) to be missionaries of the great truths in which alone there is any well-being for mankind individually or collectively, I should not care though a revolution were to exterminate every person in Great Britain and Ireland who has £500 a year. Many very amiable persons would perish, but what is the world the better for such amiable persons ? But among the missionaries whom I would reserve, a large proportion would consist of speculative Tories : for it is an ideal Toryism, an ideal King, Lords, and Commons that they venerate ; it is old England as opposed to the new, but it is old England as she might be, not as she is. It seems to me that the Toryism of Wordsworth, of Coleridge (if he can be called a Tory), of Southey even, and of many others whom I could mention, is tout bonnement a reverence for government in the abstract : it means, that they are duly sensible that it is good for man to be ruled ; to submit both his body and mind to the guidance of a higher intelligence and virtue. It is, therefore, the direct antithesis of Liberalism, which is for making every man his own guide and sovereign-master, and letting him think for himself, and do exactly as he judges best for himself, giving other men leave to persuade him if they can by evidence, but forbidding him to give way to authority ; and still less allowing them to constrain him more than the existence and tolerable necessity of every man’s person and property renders indispensably necessary. It is difficult to conceive a more thorough ignorance of man’s nature, and of what is necessary for his happiness, or what degree of happiness and virtue he is capable of attaining, than this system implies. But I cannot help regretting that the men who are best capable of struggling against these narrow views and mischievous heresies should chain themselves, full of life and vigour

[p. 16]

1831
—
Aetat. 25.

as they are, to the inanimate corpses of dead political and religious systems, never more to be revived. The same ends require altered means; we have no new principles, but we want new machines constructed on the old principles; those we had before are worn out. Instead of cutting a safe channel for the stream of events, these people would dam it up till it breaks down everything and spreads devastation over a whole region.

Another acquaintance which I have recently made is that of Mr. Carlyle, whom I believe you are also acquainted with. I have long had a very keen relish for his articles in the Edinburgh and Foreign Reviews, which I formerly thought to be such consummate nonsense; and I think he improves upon a nearer acquaintance. He does not seem to me so entirely the reflection or shadow of the great German writers as I was inclined to consider him; although undoubtedly his mind has derived from their inspiration whatever breath of life is in it. He seems to me as a man who has had his eyes unsealed, and who now looks round him and sees the aspects of things with his own eyes, but by the light supplied by others; not the pure light of day, but by another light compounded of the same simple rays, but in different proportions. He has by far the widest liberality and tolerance (not in the sense which Coleridge justly disavows, but in the good sense) that I have met with in any one; and he differs from most men, who see as much as he does into the defects of the age, by a circumstance greatly to his advantage in my estimation, that he looks for a safe landing before and not behind; he sees that if we could replace things as they once were, we should only retard the final issue, as we should in all human probability go on just as we then did, and arrive again at the very place where we now stand. Carlyle intends staying in town all the winter; he has brought his wife up to town (whom I have not seen enough of yet to be able to judge of her at all); his object was to treat with booksellers about a work which he wishes to publish, but he has given up this for the present, finding that no bookseller will publish anything

[p. 17]

but a political pamphlet in the present state of excitement. In fact, literature is suspended; men neither read nor write. Accordingly, Carlyle means to employ his stay here in improving his knowledge of what is going on in the world, at least in this part of it, I mean in that part of the world of ideas and feelings which corresponds to London. He is a great hunter-out of acquaintances; he hunted me out, or rather hunted out the author of certain papers in the Examiner (the first, as he said, which he had ever seen in a newspaper, hinting that the age was not the best of all possible ages): and his acquaintance is the only substantial good I have yet derived from writing those papers, and a much greater one than I expected when I wrote them. He has also, through me, sought the acquaintance of Fonblanque (of the Examiner), whom I found him to be an admirer of, and who, though as little of a mystic as most men, reads his writings with pleasure. I expect great good from Fonblanque; he is fashioned for the work of the day, as befits one who works for the day, but he is one of those on whom one may most completely rely for being ready to turn over a new leaf when the old one is read through.

1831
—
Aetat. 25.

I have to add yet another new acquaintance to all these, and one who is by no means the least remarkable among them; I mean Stephen,1 the counsel to the Colonial Office, son of the Master in Chancery. I have only yet seen him two or three times, but I hope to see much more of him, especially as I have now gone to live in his immediate neighbourhood, at Kensington. I have hardly met with any person who seems to me to take such just views of the age and of futurity as he does; to be so free from any exaggeration or one-sidedness, and to combine the speculative and the practical in so just a proportion. He cannot fail to exercise hereafter a great influence over the destinies of his country, not so much perhaps by what he does, as by what he makes other persons do. He is at this moment not only the direct-ing spirit of the Colonial Office, but of several other

[p. 18]

1831
—
Aetat. 25.

departments of the Government: under great restraints and disadvantages, of course, from the unteachable quality of those placed over him and their dread of anything like a principle, arising from their consciousness of inability to comprehend in one view all that is involved in it, and all the consequences to which it leads. Stephen is reputed a saint: I do not know in what sense he is one, though I know that he carries the observance of the Sabbath to the extent of puritanism. But if all the English evangelicals were like him, I think I should attend their Exeter Hall meetings myself, and subscribe to their societies. I will write to you at greater length about Stephen when I have seen more of him.

As for our common friends and acquaintances here, I have but little to tell you concerning them. Mrs. [John] Austin will, of course, write to you. I do not know whether the subscription for endowing the Jurisprudence chair is yet full, but no doubt is entertained that it will be so. Mr. Austin is still engaged in bringing out his first eight lectures, which are soon to appear. He is in good health and spirits upon the whole. I have not seen or heard anything about Maurice; I hope our separation is not to be everlasting. Wilson has very recently returned from Germany, where he has spent about a year. I have seen very little of Charles Buller; you are probably aware that he is not in this Parliament, but he is sure of being returned for Liskeard when the Bill passes. The greatest change that has occurred in any one since I saw you is in Roebuck; he has pulled off his strait-jacket, and now moves freely; his mental powers are no longer enslaved by fixed forms of words, and phrases strung together syllogistically with the false appearance of Euclidean demonstration. His intellect has greatly expanded, and the asperities of his character are much softened; and though there still remains, and possibly may always remain, much in his mental character which you and I would greatly object to, I have now no doubt of his being a useful, powerful, and constantly improving member of the

[p. 19]

only Church which has now any real existence, namely, that of writers and orators. The Colonisation scheme is going on prosperously. They have formed a plan for a new colony, to be settled on their principles on the coast of Southern Australia, near the place where the newly discovered navigable river discharges itself into the sea. They are endeavouring to form a land company to settle the country, and have the promise of an excellent charter from Government when the company is formed. The Colonial Office I believe to be heartily with them at present. Our friend Graham has gone into the scheme with his usual vigour, and is now one of their leading minds: he wrote their last two pamphlets. Wakefield now moves openly in the thing, though it is not declared publicly that he was the originator of it; but there is no reason now for keeping his connection with it altogether a secret, as he has made himself very advantageously known to the public by, really, a most remarkable book on the punishment of death, founded on the observations he made while in Newgate. You are aware that our old enemy, Wilmot Horton, has gone to Ceylon as governor, so that he no longer stands in the way of a rational scheme of colonisation. The St. Simonists are making immense progress in France, and are doing great good there; France has nobody comparable to them, on the whole. They talk of sending missionaries here; that will do them no good, I think. This letter, I hope, will call forth an equally long one from you. I beg to be duly remembered to Mrs. John Sterling.—Yours faithfully,

1831
—
Aetat. 25.

J. S. Mill.

Notes

  1. 1[Sir James Stephen.]

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 57 of the 1910 edition (printed page 3), showing letter 4.
Printed page 3 · scan leaf 57 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 58 of the 1910 edition (printed page 4), showing letter 4.
Printed page 4 · scan leaf 58 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 59 of the 1910 edition (printed page 5), showing letter 4.
Printed page 5 · scan leaf 59 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 60 of the 1910 edition (printed page 6), showing letter 4.
Printed page 6 · scan leaf 60 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 61 of the 1910 edition (printed page 7), showing letter 4.
Printed page 7 · scan leaf 61 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 62 of the 1910 edition (printed page 8), showing letter 4.
Printed page 8 · scan leaf 62 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 63 of the 1910 edition (printed page 9), showing letter 4.
Printed page 9 · scan leaf 63 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 64 of the 1910 edition (printed page 10), showing letter 4.
Printed page 10 · scan leaf 64 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 65 of the 1910 edition (printed page 11), showing letter 4.
Printed page 11 · scan leaf 65 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 66 of the 1910 edition (printed page 12), showing letter 4.
Printed page 12 · scan leaf 66 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 67 of the 1910 edition (printed page 13), showing letter 4.
Printed page 13 · scan leaf 67 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 68 of the 1910 edition (printed page 14), showing letter 4.
Printed page 14 · scan leaf 68 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 69 of the 1910 edition (printed page 15), showing letter 4.
Printed page 15 · scan leaf 69 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 70 of the 1910 edition (printed page 16), showing letter 4.
Printed page 16 · scan leaf 70 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 71 of the 1910 edition (printed page 17), showing letter 4.
Printed page 17 · scan leaf 71 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 72 of the 1910 edition (printed page 18), showing letter 4.
Printed page 18 · scan leaf 72 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 73 of the 1910 edition (printed page 19), showing letter 4.
Printed page 19 · scan leaf 73 of 378Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter 4 of 165 · printed pp. 3–19 · scan leaf 57 of 378

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot, 1910, pp. 3–19.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationJ. S. Mill to John Sterling, October 1831, “To John Sterling,”. In The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot (London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910), pp. 3–19. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/4/.

BibTeX@incollection{mill-letters-vol1-1910-letter-0004,
  author    = {J. S. Mill},
  title     = {To John Sterling,, October 1831},
  booktitle = {The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I},
  publisher = {London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910},
  year      = {1910},
  pages     = {3--19},
  note      = {Edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot. Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/4/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/4/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.