To John Sterling.
I have been reading your review of Tennyson for the second time…
To John Sterling.
India House, November 1842.
1842
—
Aetat. 36.
I have been reading your review of Tennyson for the second time, after an interval of several weeks. I have found more difference than I expected in our judgments of particular poems, and I will not pretend that I think yours the more likely to be right, for I have faith in my own feelings of Art; but I have read and reflected so little on the subject compared with you, that I have no doubt you could give many more reasons for your opinions than I should be fully competent to appreciate. Still, I think I could justify my own feelings on grounds of my own, if I took time enough to meditate; but I doubt its being worth while—the thing is not in my fach.
[p. 122]1842
—
Aetat. 36.
The preliminary remarks are very delightful reading, and I think they do as much as can be done to render this age, what Carlyle says no age is, romantic to itself. But I think Tennyson, having taken up the same theory, has miserably misunderstood it. Because mechanical things may generate grand results he thinks that there is grandeur in the naked statement of their most mechanical details. Ebenezer Elliott has written a most fiery ode on the Press, which is a mechanical thing like a railroad, but the mechanicality is kept studiously out of sight. Tennyson obtrudes it.—Ever yours,
J. S. Mill.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

