To John Sterling.
you are writing the sort of paper you mention.
To John Sterling.
India House, November 1842.
My dear Sterling,—I am very glad indeed to hear that
you are writing the sort of paper you mention. As to Tennyson, you were right in getting so much praise of him into the Quarterly by no greater sacrifice than leaving some of the best of the earlier poems unmentioned. I do not differ from your principle that the highest forms of poetry cannot be built upon obsolete beliefs—although what you say of the “Ancient Mariner” and “Christabel” seems to me true of the “Lady of Shalott,” and the objection does not seem to me to lie strongly against the “Lotos-Eaters” or “Œnone.” But neither is the idyl one of the highest forms of poetry—neither Spenser, Tasso, nor Ovid could have been what they were by means of that. And greatly as I admire “Michael” and its compeers, that is not the crowning glory of Wordsworth. And how poor surely is “Dora” compared with some dozen of Wordsworth’s poems of that kind.
My remark on mechanical details does not apply to “Burleigh,” which seems to me Tennyson’s best in that style; not much, if at all, to the “Gardener’s Daughter,” a good deal to “Dora”—which I do not like; a little to some parts of “Locksley Hall”; but in a most intense degree to such things as “Audley Court,” “Walking to the Mail,” the introduction to “Morte d’Arthur”; and the type
[p. 123]of what I object to is the three lines of introduction to “Godiva,” which he has stuck in, as it were, in defiance. But, mind, I do not give my opinion as worth anything, to you especially, and my feeling is only to be reckoned as that of one person, competent in so far as capable of almost any degree of exalté feeling from poetry.
1842
—
Aetat. 36.
Have you seen Macaulay’s old-Roman ballads? If you have not, do not judge of them from extracts, which give you the best passages without the previous preparation. They are in every way better, and nearer to what one might fancy Campbell would have made them, than I thought Macaulay capable of. He has it not in him to be a great poet; there is no real genius in the thing, no revelation from the depths either of thought or feeling; but that being allowed for, there is real verve, and much more of the simplicity of ballad poetry than one would at all expect. The latter part of the “Battle of the Lake Regillus,” and the whole of “Virginia,” seem to me admirable.—
Yours ever,
J. S. Mill.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

