To J. F. Mollett,
Sir,—Your note of the 30th places Mr. Lovett's refusal to serve in the militia in a…
To J. F. Mollett,
with reference to a Mr. Lovett, who had been brought before a magistrate for refusing to serve in the militia. He pleaded that, as he had no vote, he was not acknowledged by the State as a citizen, and there was no compulsion upon him to serve. He took his stand upon the cry, “No vote, no musket.”
30th December 1847.
Sir,—Your note of the 30th places Mr. Lovett's refusal to serve in the militia in a different light from that in which I had considered it. Knowing nothing of the fact except from your circular, I had surmised that it might have been founded on such principles as those professed by the Peace Society, principles with which I wholly disagree, as, though I think it an effect of the progress of improvement to put an end to war, I regard war as an infinitely less evil than systematic submission to injustice.
With the principles on which it appears that Mr. Lovett really acted I have much more sympathy, though I do not think, to use your words, that “he would have been false to the principles he professed had he acted otherwise,” any more than I think him bound by those principles to refuse the payment of taxes. To resist a social system which one thinks wrong by disobeying the laws in detail
[p. 134]1847
—
Aetat. 41.
must, I think, depend for its justification in each particular case on the circumstances and motives which dictated it; but if adopted and acted upon as a principle it would render government impossible under any institutions yet devised, since, in a democracy, minorities might claim and exercise the right of obstructing the execution of all laws which they disapproved.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

