To W. J. Fox, · on religious and moral instruction in schools.
The stupid doctrines which alone the plan excludes…
To W. J. Fox,
on religious and moral instruction in schools.
End of 1849.
My dear Sir,—I return the Resolutions with some notes on two or three of them. You will see that, with the exception of the eighth Resolution, which seems to me objectionable in toto, the fault I find with the plan is that it is a kind of compromise—since it admits as much religious instruction as is given in the Irish National Schools, and not admits, but demands, what is called moral instruction.
The stupid doctrines which alone the plan excludes, generally lie dead in the minds of children, having hardly any effect, good or bad—the real harm being done by the circulation of the common moralities. I know that compromises are often inevitable in practice, but I think they should be left to the enemy to propose—reformers should assert principles and only accept compromises.
[p. 150]1849
—
Aetat. 43.
I am very glad to see you active, and on so important a subject. There is something like a stir beginning again among the Liberal members of Parliament, which will give a chance of a good following to whoever takes the lead in anything useful.
Notes appended to the above letter.
3rd Resolution.—I would omit the words including moral instruction. What the sort of people who will have the management of any such schools mean by moral instruction, is much the same thing as what they mean by religious instruction, only lowered to the world's practice. It means cramming the children directly with all the common professions about what is right and wrong, and about the worth of different objects in life, and filling them indirectly with the spirit of all the notions on such matters which vulgar-minded people are in the habit of acting on without consciously professing. I know it is impossible to prevent much of this from being done—but the less of it there is the better, and I would not set people upon doing more of it than they might otherwise do, by insisting expressly on moral instruction.
If it were possible to provide for giving real moral instruction it would be worth more than all else that schools can do. But no programme of moral instruction, which would be really good, would have a chance of being assented to or followed by the manager of a general scheme of public instruction in the present state of people's minds.
5th Resolution.—The National Schools of Ireland are, I believe, the best among existing models; but they are unsectarian only in a narrow sense. They are not unsectarian as between Christian and non-Christian. They are not purely for secular instruction. They use selections from the Bible, and therefore teach the general recognition of that book as containing the system and history of creation and the commands of an all-wise and good being. Any system of instruction, which does this, contains, I conceive, a great part of all the mischief done by a purely
[p. 151]Church or purely Dissenting education. Is it not better, even in policy, to make the omission altogether of religion from State schools the avowed object ?
1849
—
Aetat. 43.
8th Resolution.—This seems to be very objectionable. If any public body were empowered to prevent a person from practising as a teacher without a certificate of competency, no person believed to think or act in opposition to any of the ordinary standards, or who is supposed to be an “unbeliever,” would ever be allowed to teach. No Socialist or even Chartist would have (especially in times of political alarm) the smallest chance. No such person could keep even a private school, much less be teacher in a public one. I have never seen the body that I would trust with the power of pronouncing persons incompetent for this or any other profession. Neither do I see what purpose this resolution is intended to answer. No doubt persons grossly incompetent do try to get a living as schoolmasters, but the remedy for this is to provide better ones, and the other resolutions ensure this in every district. Besides, this evil would soon take care of itself if the mass of people had even a little education.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.


