To Edward Herford; · a sequel to the preceding letter.
Sir,—I am sensible of the compliment paid to me by the promoters of the “Poor Law Reform…
To Edward Herford;
a sequel to the preceding letter.
February 1850.
1850
—
Aetat. 43.
Sir,—I am sensible of the compliment paid to me by the promoters of the “Poor Law Reform Association” in their willingness to make some modifications in the terms of their address if I shall thus be enabled to concur in it. But my differences from them are too wide to admit of co-operation. My objection is not founded on any mischief which I expect from the practical recommendations in the address, but on what seems to me the merely superficial character of everything that it proposes or contemplates. The plan will, I conceive, have no effect at all on the permanent and hereditary paupers, who form the great mass of the pauperism of the country. Manufacturing operatives are, as you say, often thrown out of employment in great numbers at once, by the vicissitudes of trade, and the means, during such intervals, of employing them so as to reproduce their subsistence would be a useful thing, doubtless, but I cannot think that it would amount to any social reform; it seems to me more the concern of the ratepayers than of any one else. Of course, I make no objection to considering and discussing the means of doing this, but it is not a thing in which I feel called upon to take a part.
It is not necessary that I should comment on the many things in your letter with which entirely I disagree; I will merely observe on a matter of fact, that, though I am aware that piecework was not the original principle either of the Irish relief works or of the ateliers nationaux, I have a most distinct recollection that in one or other, and I believe in both, it was had recourse to on failure of the original plans, and with the effects which I mentioned.
—I am, Sir, yours truly,
J. S. Mill.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.
