To Lord Monteagle, · the Whig statesman, in acknowledgment of his pamphlet on the Representation of Minorities.

J. S. MillLord Monteagle

you sent me is intended to meet a difficulty which has always appeared to me one of the…

20 · III · 1853Printed pp. 173–175

To Lord Monteagle,

the Whig statesman, in acknowledgment of his pamphlet on the Representation of Minorities.

Dear Lord Monteagle,—The suggestion in the paper

you sent me is intended to meet a difficulty which has always appeared to me one of the chief stumbling-blocks of representative government. “Whoever could devise a means of preventing minorities from being, as they now are, swamped, and enabling them to obtain a share of the representation proportional to their numbers and not more than proportional, would render a great service.” Whether the plan proposed would do this, and to what objections it may be liable, I should be sorry to be obliged to say without more consideration than I have yet given to it. One thing seems to me evident; that if this plan were adopted, no constituency ought to elect fewer than three members. For if the number be two, as the proposed plan would enable a minority to count for double its number, any minority exceeding one-third could ensure half the representation; which, unless the minority can be presumed to consist of wiser or better persons than the majority, would be contrary to all principle.

1853
—
Aetat. 46.

One very strong recommendation of the plan of cumulative votes occurs to me, which is not mentioned in the Memorandum. If we suppose a voter to determine his vote by the personal merits of the candidates, and not solely by their being on the same side with himself in the common

[p. 174]

1853
—
Aetat. 46.

party divisions, it will frequently happen that he greatly prefers one of the candidates, and is comparatively indifferent to all the others, so that he would, if he could, give all his votes to that one. This wish is most likely to be felt by the best voters, and in favour of the best candidates, and it seems to me right that strength of preference should have some influence as well as the mere number of persons preferring. To allow the cumulative vote would be one of the best ways which occur to me of enabling quality of support to count as well as quantity. The candidates most likely to benefit by it would be those who were too good for the mass of the constituency; those, for example, whose election was endangered by some honest but unpopular vote or opinion, and who for that very reason would probably be supported with redoubled zeal by the better minority, and their election made the first object.

I do not see the force of your objection respecting bribery. No doubt if a candidate depended solely on bribed votes, he would find it easier to succeed if every bribed voter could give two or three votes for him instead of one. But to carry an election by bribing everybody is only possible with smaller constituencies than ought to exist. In large or even moderate constituencies, the bribed are only the two or three hundred who in a nearly balanced state of parties turn the scale. Now in this case the minority can get no corrupt advantage from the cumulative vote unless they limit their aim to a part of the representation ; and if they do this, the cumulative vote may probably enable them to attain their object without bribing. Thus, if there are two members to be returned, and the minority will be content with returning one, a minority exceeding a third would have no inducement to bribe, but only a minority of less than a third. At present the reverse is the case : a minority of less than a third has no chance of succeeding by bribery, while a minority of more than a third has. The cumulative vote therefore displaces, but does not seem to me to increase, the inducement to bribe.

The point is well worth consideration in framing a new Reform Bill, which, to be any real improvement, ought not

[p. 175]

1853
—
Aetat. 46.

to be a mere imitation and extension of the Reform Bill of 1832. There are, as it seems to me, three great and perfectly safe improvements, which could hardly be successfully resisted if a Government proposed them. One is to have no small constituencies : this might be done by grouping the small towns into districts. Another is to let in the principle of an educational qualification, by requiring from all voters, in addition to any property or ratepaying conditions that may be imposed, at least reading, writing, and arithmetic. The third is to open the franchise to women who fulfil the same conditions on which it is granted to men ; in the same manner as they already vote for boards of guardians. They have as much interest in good laws as men have, and would vote at least as well. Electoral districts seem to me needless, and ballot would now be a step backward instead of forward.

I beg to apologise for not having answered sooner, but I did not like to give an opinion without consideration, and being pressed for time I was not able before to give the subject even the degree of consideration which I have now done.—I am, dear Lord Monteagle, very truly yours,

J. S. Mill.

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 233 of the 1910 edition (printed page 173), showing letter 73.
Printed page 173 · scan leaf 233 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 234 of the 1910 edition (printed page 174), showing letter 73.
Printed page 174 · scan leaf 234 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 235 of the 1910 edition (printed page 175), showing letter 73.
Printed page 175 · scan leaf 235 of 378Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter 73 of 165 · printed pp. 173–175 · scan leaf 233 of 378

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot, 1910, pp. 173–175.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationJ. S. Mill to Lord Monteagle, 20 March 1853, “To Lord Monteagle, · the Whig statesman, in acknowledgment of his pamphlet on the Representation of Minorities.”. In The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot (London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910), pp. 173–175. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/73/.

BibTeX@incollection{mill-letters-vol1-1910-letter-0073,
  author    = {J. S. Mill},
  title     = {To Lord Monteagle, · the Whig statesman, in acknowledgment of his pamphlet on the Representation of Minorities., 20 March 1853},
  booktitle = {The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I},
  publisher = {London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910},
  year      = {1910},
  pages     = {173--175},
  note      = {Edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot. Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/73/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/73/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.