To Sir William Molesworth, · in reply to a letter asking Mill's opinion on the argument put forward by the opponents of a Succession Duty, that “it would lead to partition of the land, which was an evil.”
Dear Molesworth,—My opinions on these subjects are very much the same with yours…
To Sir William Molesworth,
in reply to a letter asking Mill's opinion on the argument put forward by the opponents of a Succession Duty, that “it would lead to partition of the land, which was an evil.”
India House, 15th May 1853.
Dear Molesworth,—My opinions on these subjects are very much the same with yours, except where they are mixed up with other subjects. I conceive that, in the present state of the distribution of wealth in this country, any additional land brought into the market is likely to be bought by rich people and not by poor. The present question, however, does not turn upon whether partition is an evil or a good—but upon whether, to save the owner from the necessity of selling part of it (in this case a very
[p. 176]1853
—
Aetat. 47.
small part), he ought to be exempted from paying his fair share of the taxes. This is so impudent a pretension that it hardly admits of any more complete exposure than is made by the simplest statement. The reason would serve just as well for dispensing them from paying any taxes whatever, or from paying their debts, for they may be unable to do either of these without selling their land. If the inheritors of land wish to keep it entire let them save the tax out of their incomes. Gladstone allows them several years to do it in. No large proprietor ought to have any difficulty in this except those who are deeply mortgaged, and the sooner they can be induced to sell the better. That is a proposition which may be very safely assumed in these days.
I do not know any writers who have discussed taxes on succession at much length, except some of the French Socialists, and they (besides that they are bad political economists) derive their arguments from premises not suited to the atmosphere of the House of Commons.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

