To Thomas Carlyle.

J. S. MillThomas Carlyle

My dear Friend,—To be moderate, I will only thank you twice…

29 · V · 1832India HousePrinted pp. 26–32

To Thomas Carlyle.

My dear Friend,—To be moderate, I will only thank you twice: once for being the first to write. The good-natured excuse which you make for my silence will not serve me. I always felt that I ought to write first, and not you; but it always seemed that there would be some better time for writing than the present one. In particular, I have had an unusual number of letters to write since I saw you, and to me it appears a very weighty matter to write a letter; there is scarcely anything that we do which requires a more complete possession of our faculties in their greatest freshness and vigour; and all the more so, because if it is elaborate it is good for little. Besides, I knew that I was corresponding with you, in some measure,

[p. 27]

through the Examiner. All this is not intended as an excuse, but a confession, that you may see what paltry reasons sufficed with me for putting off the discharge of a duty. But it is very idle to complain of my own faults instead of mending them, as every man can, if he will, and as I trust I yet shall, all the less slowly from having known you.

1832
—
Aetat. 26.

I believe I have fulfilled most of your parting injunctions; some of them, however, less soon than I might and ought. For several weeks after your departure I waited for some time when it would be quite convenient to call upon poor Glen, till finding that no such moment arrived I did at last what I might have done at first, disregarded convenience and did the thing out of hand; and the great joy which it seemed to give him satisfied me not that I had done right, for I was thinking much more of you than of him, but that you had done right in instigating me to call upon him. Since that time we have seen each other frequently, and I have cultivated his acquaintance the more because he has so few persons in London besides me who are at all able to help or encourage him. I have been much struck by the exact manner in which every opinion that you have ever expressed to me about him has been proved true by what I have since seen of him. Mrs. Carlyle's opinion in so far as it differed from yours was, I am satisfied, entirely groundless. I am somewhat doubtful, however, how far he is capable of deriving much advantage of an intellectual kind from the intercourse of others; his mind seems to be always in his own thoughts and in them only, and these not matured but extemporaneous; it seems almost time thrown away to give out thoughts to him, he seems never to lay hold of them. But if any one could teach him to make a proper use of his own materials it would be doing to him an unspeakable service, and to others much good through his means. I do not see my way clearly to being able to assist him in this respect, but I see that our intercourse affords some sort of satisfaction to him, and therefore probably does him some kind of good; what and how much will doubtless

[p. 28]

1832
—
Aetat. 26.

in time be made manifest. He talks of writing to you, and I am sure that it would make him extremely happy to hear from you; what he saw of you has evidently made a very deep impression upon him. I have also called upon Fraser—only once, however; but in his case there was not the same strong inducement; I have no doubt that we shall see more of each other.

Your parting gift, the paper on Biography and on Johnson, has been more precious to me than I well know how to state. I have read it over and over till I could almost repeat it by heart, and have derived from it more edification and more comfort than from all else that I have read for years past. I have moreover lent it to various persons, whom I thought likely to reap the same benefits from it, and have in no instance been disappointed; among others to some in whom it has created, or increased, a more earnest desire to see and know you, and who are most worthy that this desire should be gratified, as I trust it one day will be, if possible, through my means, unless an iron necessity, insuperable by the free will of man, should hereafter, as heretofore, prevent.

Thanks for what you tell me respecting your recent occupations. I look forward with very delightful anticipations to your review of the Corn Law Rhymer, and to your paper on Goethe: it was a disappointment to me that the former did not appear in the last Edinburgh, though I knew it was scarcely possible. Taylor1 tells me that Southey is writing an article on the same subject, and is in communication with the author, who is a real working man named Reuben Elliott.2 I have seen no review of his poems as yet, except in the Monthly Repository, the Unitarian periodical edited by Mr. Fox, whom I conjecture to be the author of this particular paper. The tone of it is very good, and there are very few persons who could have written it, but I think it misses the most striking aspect under which the poems can be looked at, viz., as works which will go down to posterity as one of the principal memorials

[p. 29]

1832
—
Aetat. 26.

of this age, from which a large portion of its character will be known which is registered in little else of a permanent nature, being chiefly those melancholy features in the position of the working class towards the other classes and towards the world altogether which have impressed upon so earnest and so loving a heart a character of almost unrelieved gloom, bitterness, and resentment. The poet just shows enough of his natural character to render the portraiture of the artificial one which is superinduced upon it more deeply impressive. I am convinced that these poems, having, as they have, sufficient intrinsic merit to live, will hereafter be a text for annotations, explanations, and commentaries without end, and that future historians (when such worthy of the name shall arise) will build largely upon them.

With respect to Goethe, there was a short obituary notice of him in the Examiner, which you would not like. I could have kept it out if I would have undertaken to write something myself at the instant; but as I knew my own ignorance, and would not write at haphazard, the matter was put into the hands of those who thought they knew, and in reality did know, more, but yet (as seems pretty obvious) not enough. The article was made up of two fragments, written by two different persons. So rare in this country is any, even the most commonplace, knowledge of Germany, that none of the other papers gave any observations at all on the extinction of the greatest man then living in Europe; and Bulwer, in his next number, that is, in the small print, drafted his notice almost entirely from that in the Examiner. How yours, in the next number, will square with it he probably cares as little as I dare say you do.

As you see the Examiner, you are acquainted with the greater part of what I have been busy about since you left us. To the papers signed “A. B.” you must add everything which has been written about France, except the notices of the cholera and a review of a trumpery pamphlet. If you should happen to see the second number of Tait's Magazine, you will see in it an article of mine, on

[p. 30]

1832
—
Aetat. 26.

a book which I have also reviewed in the Examiner, by our acquaintance, Cornewall Lewis. If you have not seen it, and will let me know how I may best send you a copy, I will do so, though unless it interest you as being mine, it scarcely will otherwise. On the whole, the opinions I have put forth in these different articles are, I think, rather not inconsistent with yours, than exactly corresponding to them, and are expressed so coldly and unimpressively that I can scarcely bear to look back upon such poor stuff. I have not yet come up even with my friends the Saint-Simonians, and it would be saying very little even if I had.

Apropos of the Saint-Simonians, they have been obliged to give up the Globe and everything else which they had in hand. The immediate causes of their stoppage are certain legal obstructions which have been thrown in their way by some of the seceding members, and a demand of 130,000 francs by the Government (very infamously allowed to reach that amount before it was brought forward) for arrears of stamps and penalties for infraction of the stamp laws. In the later numbers of the Globe there was, I think, on the whole, some evidence of improvement in their views and feelings. Enfantin and about fifty more, among whom are our two friends D'Eichthal and Duveyrier, have now retired to a place called Menilmontant, at a short distance out of Paris, where they are all living together, and are employed, as they assert, in training themselves to preach to the world by their example, which, they are beginning to find out, is after all the most impressive and in every way profitable aspect of the life even of those whose vocation it is to be the speakers of the Word. This is decidedly un progrès, as they would say; and if you believe them, their present state, like everything else which has happened to them or to any son of Adam, is for the best, that is, for the greatest ultimate success of the Saint-Simonian faith. It is difficult to conjecture how far this optimism of theirs is itself a faith, or a mere trick of self-deluding vanity, determined to put the best face upon everything, both to themselves and

[p. 31]

1832
—
Aetat. 26.

others. I do not know many of the particulars of their life at Menilmontant, but it appears that one feature of it is to do without domestic service, which they consider a vestige of slavery, and they take their turns to perform all menial offices for one another. I do not know how they reconcile this with their maxim, à chacun selon sa capacité, but I suppose they have some salve or other for it. Their adoration for Enfantin seems to be on the increase rather than on the wane, and it is well to reverence the best man they know, but I wish they had a better still.

With regard to politics, their aspect of things has somewhat changed since you wrote, and the momentary check sustained by Radicalism has been converted into a triumph far more complete than could have been achieved otherwise. The Tory party, at least the present Tory party, is now utterly annihilated. Peace be with it. All its elevated character had long gone out of it, and instead of a Falkland it had but a Croker, instead of a Johnson nothing better than a Phillpotts. Wellington himself found that if he meant to be minister he must be a Whig; and the rest of his party, though in the main Whigs already, did not choose that particular phasis of Whiggery, and determined to be nothing at all; and truly they had no very great step to make into absolute nonentity. There is now nothing definite and determinate in politics except Radicalism, and we shall have nothing but Radicals and Whigs for a long time to come, until society shall have worked itself into some new shape, not to be exactly foreseen and described now.

Mrs. Austin has been very far from well of late, but is nearly recovered. She often talks of Mrs. Carlyle and you. Austin began lecturing immediately after your departure, and part of my occupation since you went away has been in attending his lectures. Buller is now here and in good health; he has written a very pleasant article in the Foreign Quarterly Review on Prince Pückler's book,1 which I think you would like to read.

I do not think I have any more facts to tell you, and

[p. 32]

1832
—
Aetat. 26.

I have filled my letter with nothing else. Another time I shall not wait for such an accumulation of what, after all, is very secondary material for a letter, especially between you and me, so little of whose conversation used ever to turn upon mere incidents. Make my heartiest remembrances to Mrs. Carlyle, and believe me most truly yours (and hers),

J. S. Mill.

Notes

  1. 1[Henry Taylor, author of “Philip van Artevelde.”]
  2. 2[His real name was Ebenezer Elliott.]
  3. 1[“Tour of a German Prince.”]

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 80 of the 1910 edition (printed page 26), showing letter 8.
Printed page 26 · scan leaf 80 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 81 of the 1910 edition (printed page 27), showing letter 8.
Printed page 27 · scan leaf 81 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 82 of the 1910 edition (printed page 28), showing letter 8.
Printed page 28 · scan leaf 82 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 83 of the 1910 edition (printed page 29), showing letter 8.
Printed page 29 · scan leaf 83 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 84 of the 1910 edition (printed page 30), showing letter 8.
Printed page 30 · scan leaf 84 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 85 of the 1910 edition (printed page 31), showing letter 8.
Printed page 31 · scan leaf 85 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 86 of the 1910 edition (printed page 32), showing letter 8.
Printed page 32 · scan leaf 86 of 378Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter 8 of 165 · printed pp. 26–32 · scan leaf 80 of 378

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot, 1910, pp. 26–32.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationJ. S. Mill to Thomas Carlyle, 29 May 1832, “To Thomas Carlyle.”. In The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot (London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910), pp. 26–32. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/8/.

BibTeX@incollection{mill-letters-vol1-1910-letter-0008,
  author    = {J. S. Mill},
  title     = {To Thomas Carlyle., 29 May 1832},
  booktitle = {The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I},
  publisher = {London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910},
  year      = {1910},
  pages     = {26--32},
  note      = {Edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot. Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/8/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/8/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.