To Arthur Hardy, of Adelaide.
and fourth volumes are as popular at Adelaide as in London.
To Arthur Hardy, of Adelaide.
29th September 1856.
1856
—
Aetat. 50.
My dear Hardy,— . . . I suppose Macaulay's third
and fourth volumes are as popular at Adelaide as in London. They are, as you say, “pleasant reading but not exactly history.” His object is to strike, and he attains it; but it is by scene-painting—he aims at
[p. 189]stronger effects than truth warrants, and so caricatures many of his personages as to leave it unaccountable how they can have done what they did. If Sarah, Duchess of Marlborough, had been nothing but a thoroughly unprincipled shrew, without talent or any one valuable or amiable quality (as he makes her), could she have been, by mere personal influence, for many years the most powerful person in England? This disregard of consistency and probability spoils the book even as a work of art. What a difference between it and Grote's "History of Greece," which is less brilliant, but far more interesting in its simple veracity, and because, instead of striving to astonish, he strives to comprehend and explain. . . .
1856
—
Aetat. 50.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

