To Henry Carleton, of Philadelphia.
Dear Sir,—The little volume which you did me the honour to send me, arrived safely…
To Henry Carleton, of Philadelphia.
East India House, 12th October 1857.
Dear Sir,—The little volume which you did me the honour to send me, arrived safely, but not until several months after the date of your letter announcing its despatch. I read it as soon as I received it, which was about a fortnight ago, and I not only agree with you throughout on the main question (of Liberty and Necessity), but also have to thank you for a very useful exposition and illustration, in small compass, of the law of association as applied to the analysis of the principal mental phenomena. I could mention points on which I differ from you; but
[p. 197]1857
—
Aetat. 51.
on several of these the difference is possibly more verbal than real. For instance, when you say on page 130 that truth is to every man what it appears to him to be, I cannot suppose you to mean that if I think poison to be wholesome food, it really is so to me, but only that I cannot help viewing as truth what presents itself to my perceptions or judgment as such. So when you say that “sin and crime exist of necessity,” I do not understand you to mean that it is necessary they should always exist; but only that when they exist, they are the necessary consequences of the causes which have produced them. I do not think you successful in the first attempt you make to reconcile your doctrine with the received notions of Divine perfection; but your theory is quite as consistent with those notions as the opposite theory. In truth, nothing can reconcile the order of nature as we know it with perfect wisdom and goodness, combined with infinite power. To make any consistent scheme, at least one of the three must be given up.
There is something doing in this country also for the “Association Philosophy.” Mr. Bain has published under the name of “The Senses and the Intellect,” the first part of a treatise on the mind, which I think you would be much pleased with. He has not yet got to your special subject, but he will soon arrive at it. Mr. Herbert Spencer’s “Principles of Psychology,” though not so sound as a whole, contains many searching analyses of complex mental phenomena, and happy applications of the principle of association. He has unfortunately put at the head of it a dissertation under the title of the “Universal Postulate,” which seems to me not only erroneous, but quite inconsistent with the philosophy of the work it is prefixed to.
I hope that like myself you have been successful in warding off your chest complaint, and that your eyesight, to which your preface alludes, is at least not getting worse.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

