To F. Sinnett, of Melbourne.
Dear Sir,—It is now some weeks since I received your letter of 23rd May…
To F. Sinnett, of Melbourne.
Blackheath, 22nd October 1857.
1857
—
Aetat. 51.
Dear Sir,—It is now some weeks since I received your letter of 23rd May, but I have not until now had time to answer your question. In principle, I am quite in favour of considering all land as the property of the State, and its rent as a fund for defraying the public expenses. But there are two objections to the application of this maxim to a country in the circumstances of Australia. One of these you have mentioned, viz., that a large immigration is most effectually attracted by granting the land in absolute property, at a price to be only once paid. I agree with you that a time comes when a colony is so far advanced in population and importance that immigration ceases to be the first object, so far as the colony itself is concerned, and that, when this time comes, the advantage of the colony should take precedence over the interest which the mother country may have in getting rid of a surplus population. But I doubt if that time has yet come in the case of Australia. A great temporary immigration has been brought about by the gold discoveries, but I should think that for retaining the immigrants the colony depends very much on the facilities allowed of acquiring land; and Englishmen do not like to settle where they cannot get land in fee. In India we have the system you desire, but that is one great reason why few English settle there; and the English who do go, and the greater number who would like to go, are always clamouring to have the system changed to one of grants in fee; and so I should think would a large part of the resident population of Australia who have not yet got land. There is a second objection which weighs with me as much as the first; the very great difficulty of levying a land tax, or any annual payment, from settlers scattered widely apart over a great wilderness. It is difficult enough, as the Americans find, to prevent squatting even when only one
[p. 199]1857
—
Aetat. 51.
payment is demanded, as a condition preliminary to occupancy. But if a payment has to be made annually I cannot but think that to collect and enforce it, if practicable at all, would require so costly an establishment as would absorb the chief part of the receipts, and be quite unsuitable to the finances of a country like Australia. In India the revenue establishments are one of the heaviest items of the public expenditure, although India in general is thickly peopled. I believe that attempts have been made formerly to collect taxes from outlying lands in the older Australian colonies, but that their failure was so complete that they were abandoned.
The newly introduced Parliamentary government of the provinces seems to have some difficulty in getting into regular play, but this will be got over in time. We are glad to hear your favourable account of your own prospects.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

