LETTER II.
I Agree with you, that if Matter evenly diffuſed through a finite Space, not ſpherical…
LETTER II.
For Mr. Bentley, at the Palace
at Worceſter.
Sir,
I Agree with you, that if Matter evenly diffuſed through a finite Space, not ſpherical, ſhould fall into a ſolid Maſs, this Maſs would affect the Figure of the whole Space, provided it were not ſoft, like the old Chaos, but ſo hard and ſolid from the Beginning, that the Weight of its protuberant Parts could not make it yield to their Preſſure. Yet by Earthquakes looſening the Parts of this Solid, the Protuberances might ſometimes ſink a little by their Weight, and thereby the Maſs might, by Degrees, approach a ſpherical Figure.
[p. [ 14 ]]The Reaſon why Matter evenly ſcattered through a finite Space would convene in the midſt, you conceive the ſame with me; but that there ſhould be a central Particle, ſo accurately placed in the middle, as to be always equally attracted on all Sides, and thereby continue without Motion, ſeems to me a Suppoſition fully as hard as to make the ſharpeſt Needle ſtand upright on its Point upon a Looking-Glaſs. For if the very mathematical Center of the central Particle be not accurately in the very mathematical Center of the attractive Power of the whole Maſs, the Particle will not be attracted equally on all Sides. And much harder it is to ſuppoſe all the Particles in an infinite Space ſhould be ſo accurately poiſed one among another, as to ſtand ſtill in a perfect Equilibrium. For I reckon this as hard as to make not one Needle only, but an infinite number of them (ſo many as there are Particles in an infinite Space) ſtand accurately poiſed upon their
[p. 15]Points. Yet I grant it poſſible, at leaſt by a divine Power; and if they were once to be placed, I agree with you that they would continue in that Poſture without Motion for ever, unleſs put into new Motion by the ſame Power. When therefore I ſaid, that Matter evenly ſpread through all Space, would convene by its Gravity into one or more great Maſſes, I underſtand it of Matter not reſting in an accurate Poiſe.
But you argue, in the next Paragraph of your Letter, that every Particle of Matter in an infinite Space, has an infinite Quantity of Matter on all Sides, and by conſequence an infinite Attraction every way, and therefore muſt reſt in Equilibrio, becauſe all Infinites are equal. Yet you ſuſpect a Paratogiſm in this Argument; and I conceive the Paratogiſm lies in the Poſition, that all Infinites are equal. The generality of Mankind conſider Infinites no other ways than indefinitely;
[p. 16]and in this Senſe, they ſay all Infinites are equal; tho' they would ſpeak more truly if they ſhould ſay, they are neither equal nor unequal, nor have any certain Difference or Proportion one to another. In this Senſe therefore, no Concluſions can be drawn from them, about the Equality, Proportions, or Differences of Things, and they that attempt to do it uſually fall into Paralogjſms. So when Men argue againſt the infinite Diviſibility of Magnitude, by ſaying, that if an Inch may be divided into an infinite Number of Parts, the Sum of thoſe Parts will be an Inch; and if a Foot may be divided into an infinite Number of Parts, the Sum of thoſe Parts muſt be a Foot, and therefore ſince all Infinites are equal, thoſe Sums muſt be equal, that is, an Inch equal to a Foot.
The Falſeneſs of the Concluſion ſhews an Error in the Premiſes, and the Error lies in the Poſition, that all Infinites are
[p. 17]equal. There is therefore another Way of conſidering Infinites uſed by Mathematicians, and that is, under certain definite Reſtrictions and Limitations, whereby Infinites are determined to have certain Differences or Proportions to one another.
Thus Dr. Wallis conſiders them in his Arithmetica Infinitorum, whereby the various Proportions of infinite Sums, he gathers the various Proportions of infinite Magnitudes: Which way of arguing is generally allowed by Mathematicians, and yet would not be good were all Infinites equal. According to the ſame way of conſidering Infinites, a Mathematician would tell you, that tho' there be an infinite Number of infinite little Parts in an Inch, yet there is twelve times that Number of ſuch Parts in a Foot, that is, the infinite Number of thoſe Parts in a Foot is not equal to, but twelve Times bigger than the infinite Number of them in an Inch. And ſo a Mathematician will tell you, that if a
[p. 18]Body ſtood in Æquilibrio between any two equal and contrary attracting infinite Forces; and if to either of theſe Forces you add any new finite attracting Force, that new Force, how little ſoever, will deſtroy their Æquilibrium, and put the Body into the ſame Motion into which it would put it were thoſe two contrary equal Forces but finite, or even none at all; ſo that in this Caſe the two equal Infinites by the Addition of a Finite to either of them, become unequal in our ways of Reckoning; and after theſe ways we muſt reckon, if from the Conſiderations of Infinites we would always draw true Concluſions.
To the laſt Part of your Letter, I anſwer, Firſt, that if the Earth (without the Moon) were placed any where with its Center in the Orbis Magnus, and ſtood ſtill there without any Gravitation or Projection, and there at once were infuſed into it, both a gravitating Energy towards
[p. [ 19 ]]the Sun, and a tranſverſe Impulſe of a juſt Quantity moving it directly in a Tangent to the Orbis Magnus; the Compounds of this Attraction and Projection would, according to my Notion, cauſe a circular Revolution of the Earth about the Sun. But the tranſverſe Impulſe muſt be a juſt Quantity; for if it be too big or too little, it will cauſe the Earth to move in ſome other Line. Secondly, I do not know any Power in Nature which would cauſe this tranſverſe Motion without the divine Arm. Blondel tells us ſomewhere in his Book of Bombs, that Plato affirms, that the Motion of the Planets is ſuch, as if they had all of them been created by God in ſome Region very remote from our Syſtem, and let fall from thence towards the Sun, and ſo ſoon as they arrived at their ſeveral Orbs, their Motion of falling turned aſide into a tranſverſe one. And this is true, ſuppoſing the gravitating Power of the Sun was double
[p. [ 20 ]]at that Moment of Time in which they all arrive at their ſeveral Orbs; but then the divine Power is here required in a double reſpect, namely, to turn the deſcending Motions of the falling Planets into a ſide Motion, and at the ſame time to double the attractive Power of the Sun. So then Gravity may put the Planets into Motion, but without the divine Power it could never put them into ſuch a circulating Motion as they have about the Sun; and therefore, for this, as well as other Reaſons, I am compelled to aſcribe the Frame of this Syſtem to an intelligent Agent.
You ſometimes ſpeak of Gravity as eſſential and inherent to Matter. Pray do not aſcribe that Notion to me; for the Cauſe of Gravity is what I do not pretend to know, and therefore would take more Time to conſider of it.
I fear what I have ſaid of Infinites, will ſeem obſcure to you; but it is enough if
[p. [ 21 ]]you underſtand, that Infinites when conſidered abſolutely without any Reſtriction or Limitation, are neither equal nor unequal, nor have any certain Proportion one to another, and therefore the Principle that all Infinites are equal, is a precarious one.
Sir, I am,
Your moſt humble Servant,
Trinity College,
Jan. 17, 1692-3.
Is. Newton.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.
![Scan leaf 15 of the 1756 edition (printed page [ 13 ]), showing letter LETTER II..](https://archive.org/download/fourlettersfroms00newt/page/n14_w600.jpg)
![Scan leaf 16 of the 1756 edition (printed page [ 14 ]), showing letter LETTER II..](https://archive.org/download/fourlettersfroms00newt/page/n15_w600.jpg)




![Scan leaf 21 of the 1756 edition (printed page [ 19 ]), showing letter LETTER II..](https://archive.org/download/fourlettersfroms00newt/page/n20_w600.jpg)
![Scan leaf 22 of the 1756 edition (printed page [ 20 ]), showing letter LETTER II..](https://archive.org/download/fourlettersfroms00newt/page/n21_w600.jpg)
![Scan leaf 23 of the 1756 edition (printed page [ 21 ]), showing letter LETTER II..](https://archive.org/download/fourlettersfroms00newt/page/n22_w600.jpg)