LETTER III.
BEcauſe you deſire Speed, I will anſwer your Letter with what Brevity I can.
LETTER III.
For Mr. Bentley, at the Palace
at Worceſter.
Sir,
BEcauſe you deſire Speed, I will anſwer your Letter with what Brevity I can. In the ſix Poſitions you lay down in the Beginning of your Letter, I agree with you. Your aſſuming the Orbis Magnus 7000 Diameters of the Earth wide, implies the Sun's horizontal Parallax to be half a Minute. Flamſteed and Caſſini have of late obſerved it to be about 10", and thus the Orbis Magnus muſt be 21,000, or in a rounder Number 20,000 Diameters of the Earth wide. Either Computation I
[p. [ 24 ]]think will do well, and I think it not worth while to alter your Numbers.
In the next Part of your Letter you lay down four other Poſitions, founded upon the ſix firſt. The firſt of theſe four ſeems very evident, ſuppoſing you take Attraction ſo generally as by it to underſtand any Force by which diſtant Bodies endeavour to come together without mechanical Impulſe. The ſecond ſeems not ſo clear; for it may be ſaid, that there might be other Syſtems of Worlds before the preſent ones, and others before thoſe, and ſo on to all paſt Eternity, and by conſequence, that Gravity may be co-eternal to Matter, and have the ſame Effect from all Eternity as at preſent, unleſs you have ſomewhere proved that old Syſtems cannot gradually paſs into new ones; or that this Syſtem had not its Original from the exhaling Matter of former decaying Syſtems, but from a Chaos of Matter evenly
[p. [ 25 ]]diſperſed throughout all Space; for ſome-thing of this Kind, I think, you ſay was the Subject of your ſixth Sermon; and the Growth of new Syſtems out of old ones, without the Mediation of a divine Power, ſeems to me apparently abſurd.
The laſt Clauſe of the ſecond Poſition I like very well. It is inconceivable, that inanimate brute Matter ſhould, without the Mediation of ſomething elſe, which is not material, operate upon, and affect other Matter without mutual Contact, as it muſt be, if Gravitation in the Senſe of Epicurus, be eſſential and inherent in it. And this is one Reaſon why I deſired you would not aſcribe innate Gravity to me. That Gravity ſhould be innate, inherent and eſſential to Matter, ſo that one Body may act upon another at a Diſtance thro’ a Vacuum, without the Mediation of any thing elſe, by and through which their Action and Force may be conveyed from
[p. 26]one to another, is to me ſo great an Abſurdity, that I believe no Man who has in philoſophical Matters a competent Faculty of thinking, can ever fall into it. Gravity muſt be cauſed by an Agent acting conſtantly according to certain Laws; but whether this Agent be material or immaterial, I have left to the Conſideration of my Readers.
Your fourth Aſſertion, that the World could not be formed by innate Gravity alone, you confirm by three Arguments. But in your firſt Argument you ſeem to make a Petitio Principii; for whereas many ancient Philoſophers and others, as well Theiſts as Atheiſts, have all allowed, that there may be Worlds and Parcels of Matter innumerable or infinite, you deny this, by repreſenting it as abſurd as that there ſhould be poſitively an infinite arithmetical Sum or Number, which is a Contradiction in Terminis; but you do not
[p. 27]prove it as abſurd. Neither do you prove, that what Men mean by an infinite Sum or Number, is a Contradiction in Nature; for a Contradiction in Terminis implies no more than an Impropriety of Speech. Thoſe things which Men underſtand by improper and contradictious Phraſes, may be ſometimes really in Nature without any Contradiction at all: a Silver Inkhorn, a Paper Lanthorn, an Iron Whetſtone, are abſurd Phraſes, yet the Things ſignified thereby, are really in Nature. If any Man ſhould ſay, that a Number and a Sum, to ſpeak properly, is that which may be numbered and ſummed, but Things infinite are numberleſs, or, as we uſually ſpeak, innumerable and ſumleſs, or inſummable, and therefore ought not to be called a Number or Sum, he will ſpeak properly enough, and your Argument againſt him will, I fear, loſe its Force. And yet if any Man ſhall take the Words, Number and Sum, in a larger Senſe, ſo
[p. 28]as to underſtand thereby Things, which in the proper way of ſpeaking are numberleſs and ſumleſs (as you ſeem to do when you allow an infinite Number of Points in a Line) I could readily allow him the Uſe of the contradictious Phraſes of innumerable Number, or ſumleſs Sum, without inferring from thence any Abſurdity in the Thing he means by thoſe Phraſes. However, if by this, or any other Argument, you have proved the Finiteneſs of the Univerſe, it follows, that all Matter would fall down from the Outſides, and convene in the Middle. Yet the Matter in falling might concrete into many round Maſſes, like the Bodies of the Planets, and theſe by attracting one another, might acquire an Obliquity of Deſcent, by means of which they might fall, not upon the great central Body, but upon the Side of it, and fetch a Compaſs about, and then aſcend again by the ſame Steps and Degrees of Motion and Velocity
[p. [ 29 ]]with which they deſcended before, much after the Manner that the Comets revolve about the Sun; but a circular Motion in concentrick Orbs about the Sun, they could never acquire by Gravity alone.
And tho’ all the Matter were divided at firſt into ſeveral Syſtems, and every Syſtem by a divine Power conſtituted like ours; yet would the Outſide Syſtems deſcend towards the Middlemoſt; ſo that this Frame of Things could not always ſubſiſt without a divine Power to conſerve it, which is the ſecond Argument; and to your third I fully aſſent.
As for the Paſſage of Plato, there is no common Place from whence all the Planets being let fall, and deſcending with uniform and equal Gravities (as Galileo ſuppoſes) would at their Arrival to their ſeveral Orbs acquire their ſeveral Velocities, with which they now revolve in
[p. 30]them. If we ſuppoſe the Gravity of all the Planets towards the Sun to be of ſuch a Quantity as it really is, and that the Motions of the Planets are turned upwards, every Planet will aſcend to twice its Height from the Sun. Saturn will aſcend till he be twice as high from the Sun as he is at preſent, and no higher; Jupiter will aſcend as high again as at preſent, that is, a little above the Orb of Saturn; Mercury will aſcend to twice his preſent Height, that is, to the Orb of Venus; and ſo of the reſt; and then by falling down again from the Places to which they aſcended, they will arrive again at their ſeveral Orbs with the ſame Velocities they had at firſt, and with which they now revolve.
But if ſo ſoon as their Motions by which they revolve are turned upwards, the gravitating Power of the Sun, by which their Aſcent is perpetually retarded,
[p. 31]be diminiſhed by one half, they will now aſcend perpetually, and all of them at all equal Diſtances from the Sun will be equally ſwift. Mercury when he arrives at the Orb of Venus, will be as ſwift as Venus; and he and Venus, when they arrive at the Orb of the Earth, will be as ſwift as the Earth; and ſo of the reſt. If they begin all of them to aſcend at once, and aſcend in the ſame Line, they will conſtantly in aſcending become nearer and nearer together, and their Motions will conſtantly approach to an Equality, and become at length ſlower than any Motion aſſignable. Suppoſe therefore, that they aſcended till they were almoſt contiguous, and their Motions inconſiderably little, and that all their Motions were at the ſame Moment of Time turned back again; or, which comes almoſt to the ſame Thing, that they were only deprived of their Motions, and let fall at that Time, they would all at once arrive at their ſeveral Orbs, each
[p. [ 32 ]]with the Velocity it had at firſt; and if their Motions were then turned Sideways, and at the ſame Time the gravitating Power of the Sun doubled, that it might be ſtrong enough to retain them in their Orbs, they would revolve in them as before their Aſcent. But if the gravitating Power of the Sun was not doubled, they would go away from their Orbs into the higheſt Heavens in parabolical Lines. Theſe Things follow from my Princ. Math. Lib. i. Prop. 33, 34, 36, 37.
I thank you very kindly for your deſigned Preſent, and reſt
Your moſt
humble Servant
to command,
Cambridge,
Feb. 25, 1692-3.
Is. Newton.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.
![Scan leaf 25 of the 1756 edition (printed page [ 23 ]), showing letter III.](https://archive.org/download/fourlettersfroms00newt/page/n24_w600.jpg)
![Scan leaf 26 of the 1756 edition (printed page [ 24 ]), showing letter III.](https://archive.org/download/fourlettersfroms00newt/page/n25_w600.jpg)
![Scan leaf 27 of the 1756 edition (printed page [ 25 ]), showing letter III.](https://archive.org/download/fourlettersfroms00newt/page/n26_w600.jpg)



![Scan leaf 31 of the 1756 edition (printed page [ 29 ]), showing letter III.](https://archive.org/download/fourlettersfroms00newt/page/n30_w600.jpg)


![Scan leaf 34 of the 1756 edition (printed page [ 32 ]), showing letter III.](https://archive.org/download/fourlettersfroms00newt/page/n33_w600.jpg)