To James Russell Lowell · [long poems prosaic]

Edgar A. PoeJames Russell Lowell

I was upon the point of fulfilling a long neglected duty and replying to Mr. Carter's…

19 · X · 1843PhiladelphiaPrinted pp. 285–286

[Æt. 34

To James Russell Lowell

[long poems prosaic]

My dear Friend,—

I was upon the point of fulfilling a long neglected duty and replying to Mr. Carter's letter, enclosing $5, when I received yours of the 13th, remitting $5 more. Believe me I am sincerely grateful to you both for your uniform kindness and consideration.

You say nothing of your health—but Mr. C. speaks of its perfect restoration, and I see, by your very MS., that you are well again, body and mind. I need not say that I am rejoiced at this—for you must know and feel that I am. When I thought of the possible loss of your eyesight, I grieved as if some dreadful misfortune were about happening to myself.

I shall look with much anxiety for your promised volume. Will it include your “Year's Life,” and other poems already published? I hope that it may; for these have not yet been fairly placed before the eye of the world. I am seeking an opportunity to do you justice in a review, and may find it in “Graham,” when your book appears. No poet in America has done so much. I have maintained this upon all occasions. Mr. Longfellow has genius, but by no means equals you in the true spirit. He is moreover so prone to imitation that I know not how to understand him at times. I am in doubt whether he should not be termed an arrant plagiarist. You have read his “Spanish Student?” I have written quite a long notice of it for Graham's December number. The play is a poor composition, with some fine poetical passages. His “Hymn to the Night,” with some strange blemishes, is glorious.—How much I should like

[p. 286]

to interchange opinions with you upon poems and poets in general! I fancy that we should agree, usually, in results, while differing, frequently, about principles. The day may come when we can discuss everything at leisure, in person.

You say that your long poem has taught you a useful lesson,—“that you are unfit to write narrative—unless in a dramatic form.” It is not you that are unfit for the task—but the task for you—for any poet. Poetry must eschew narrative—except, as you say, dramatically. I mean to say that the true poetry—the highest poetry— must eschew it. The Iliad is not the highest. The connecting links of a narrative—the frequent passages which have to serve the purpose of binding together the parts of the story, are necessarily prose, from their very explanatory nature. To color them—to gloss over their prosaic nature—(for this is the most which can be done) requires great skill. Thus Byron, who was no artist, is always driven, in his narrative, to fragmentary passages, eked out with asterisks. Moore succeeds better than any one. His “Alciphron” is wonderful in the force, grace, and nature of its purely narrative passages:—but pardon me for prosing.

I send you the paper with my life and portrait. The former is true in general—the latter particularly false. It does not convey the faintest idea of my person. No one of my family recognized it. But this is a point of little importance. You will see, upon the back of the biography, an announcement that I was to assume the editorship of the “Museum.” This was unauthorized. I never did edit it. The review of “Graham’s Magazine” was written by H. B. Hirst—a young poet of this city. Who is to write your life for “Graham”? It is a pity that so many of these biographies were entrusted to Mr. Griswold. He certainly lacks independence, or judgment, or both.

I have tried in vain to get a copy of your “Year’s Life” in Philadelphia. If you have one, and could spare it, I would be much obliged.

Do write me again when you have leisure, and believe me,

Your most sincere friend,

Edgar A. Poe.

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 315 of the 1919 edition (printed page 285), showing letter 193.
Printed page 285 · scan leaf 315 of 580Open the full scan
Scan leaf 316 of the 1919 edition (printed page 286), showing letter 193.
Printed page 286 · scan leaf 316 of 580Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter 193 of 360 · printed pp. 285–286 · scan leaf 315 of 580

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
Nineteenth Century Letters, selected and Edited, with an Introduction (The Modern Student's Library), 1919, pp. 285–286.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationEdgar A. Poe to James Russell Lowell, 19 October 1843, “To James Russell Lowell · [long poems prosaic]”. In Nineteenth Century Letters, selected and Edited, with an Introduction (The Modern Student's Library) (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1919), pp. 285–286. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/nineteenth-century-letters-1919/193/.

BibTeX@incollection{nineteenth-century-letters-1919-letter-0193,
  author    = {Edgar A. Poe},
  title     = {To James Russell Lowell · [long poems prosaic], 19 October 1843},
  booktitle = {Nineteenth Century Letters},
  publisher = {New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1919},
  year      = {1919},
  pages     = {285--286},
  note      = {Selected and Edited, with an Introduction (The Modern Student's Library). Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/nineteenth-century-letters-1919/193/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/nineteenth-century-letters-1919/193/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.