To John Forster · [in praise of the “life of goldsmith”]

Charles DickensJohn Forster

I finished Goldsmith yesterday, after dinner…

22 · IV · 1848Devonshire TerracePrinted pp. 372–375

[Æt. 36]

To John Forster

[in praise of the “life of goldsmith”]

My dear Forster,—

I finished Goldsmith yesterday, after dinner, having read it from the first page to the last with the greatest care and attention.

As a picture of the time, I really think it impossible to give it too much praise. It seems to me to be the very essence of all about the time that I have ever seen in biography or fiction, presented in most wise and humane lights, and in a thousand new and just aspects I have never liked Johnson half so well. Nobody's contempt for Boswell ought to be capable of increase, but I have never seen him in my mind's eye half so plainly.

[p. 373]

The introduction of him is quite a masterpiece. I should point to that, if I didn't know the author, as being done by somebody with a remarkably vivid conception of what he narrated, and a most admirable and fanciful power of communicating it to another. All about Reynolds is charming: and the first account of the Literary Club and of Beauclerc as excellent a piece of description as ever I read in my life. But to read the book is to be in the time. It lives again in as fresh and lively a manner as if it were presented on an impossibly good stage by the very best actors that ever lived, or by the real actors come out of their graves on purpose.

And as to Goldsmith himself, and his life, and the tracing of it out in his own writings, and the manful and dignified assertion of him without any sobs, whines, or convulsions of any sort, it is throughout a noble achievement, of which, apart from any private and personal affection for you, I think (and really believe) I should feel proud, as one who had no indifferent perception of these books of his—to the best of my remembrance—when little more than a child. I was a little afraid in the beginning, when he committed those very discouraging imprudences, that you were going to champion him somewhat indiscriminately; but I very soon got over that fear, and found reason in every page to admire the sense, calmness, and moderation with which you made the love and admiration of the reader cluster about him from his youth, and strengthen with his strength—and weakness too, which is better still.

I don't quite agree with you in two small respects. First, I question very much whether it would have been a good thing for every great man to have had his Boswell, inasmuch that I think that two Boswells, or three at most, would have made great men extraordinarily false, and would have set them on always playing a part, and would have made distinguished people about them for ever restless and distrustful. I can imagine a succession of Boswells bringing about a tremendous state of falsehood in society, and playing the very devil with confidence and friendship. Secondly, I cannot help objecting to that practice (begun, I think, or greatly enlarged

[p. 374]

by Hunt) of italicising lines and words and whole passages in extracts, without some very special reason indeed. It does appear to be a kind of assertion of the editor over the reader—almost over the author himself—which grates upon me. The author might almost as well do it himself to my thinking, as a disagreeable thing; and it is such a strong contrast to the modest, quiet, tranquil beauty of “The Deserted Village,” for instance, that I would almost as soon hear “the town crier” speak the lines. The practice always reminds me of a man seeing a beautiful view, and not thinking how beautiful it is half so much as what he shall say about it.

In that picture at the close of the third book (a most beautiful one) of Goldsmith sitting looking out of window at the Temple trees, you speak of the “gray-eyed” rooks. Are you sure they are “gray-eyed”? The raven’s eye is a deep lustrous black, and so, I suspect, is the rook’s, except when the light shines full into it.

I have reserved for a closing word—though I don’t mean to be eloquent about it, being far too much in earnest—the admirable manner in which the case of the literary man is stated throughout this book. It is splendid. I don’t believe that any book was ever written, or anything ever done or said, half so conducive to the dignity and honour of literature as “The Life and Adventures of Oliver Goldsmith,” by J. F., of the Inner Temple. The gratitude of every man who is content to rest his station and claims quietly on literature, and to make no feint of living by anything else, is your due for evermore. I have often said, here and there, when you have been at work upon the book, that I was sure it would be; and I shall insist on that debt being due to you (though there will be no need for insisting about it) as long as I have any tediousness and obstinacy to bestow on anybody. Lastly, I never will hear the biography compared with Boswell’s except under vigorous protest. For I do say that it is mere folly to put into opposite scales a book, however amusing and curious, written by an unconscious coxcomb like that, and one which surveys and grandly understands the characters of all the illustrious company that move in it.

My dear Forster, I cannot sufficiently say how proud

[p. 375]

I am of what you have done, or how sensible I am of being so tenderly connected with it. When I look over this note, I feel as if I had said no part of what I think; and yet if I were to write another I should say no more, for I can't get it out. I desire no better for my fame, when my personal dustiness shall be past the control of my love of order, than such a biographer and such a critic. And again I say, most solemnly, that literature in England has never had, and probably never will have, such a champion as you are, in right of this book.

Ever affectionately,

Charles Dickens.

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 402 of the 1919 edition (printed page 372), showing letter 245.
Printed page 372 · scan leaf 402 of 580Open the full scan
Scan leaf 403 of the 1919 edition (printed page 373), showing letter 245.
Printed page 373 · scan leaf 403 of 580Open the full scan
Scan leaf 404 of the 1919 edition (printed page 374), showing letter 245.
Printed page 374 · scan leaf 404 of 580Open the full scan
Scan leaf 405 of the 1919 edition (printed page 375), showing letter 245.
Printed page 375 · scan leaf 405 of 580Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter 245 of 360 · printed pp. 372–375 · scan leaf 402 of 580

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
Nineteenth Century Letters, selected and Edited, with an Introduction (The Modern Student's Library), 1919, pp. 372–375.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationCharles Dickens to John Forster, 22 April 1848, “To John Forster · [in praise of the “life of goldsmith”]”. In Nineteenth Century Letters, selected and Edited, with an Introduction (The Modern Student's Library) (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1919), pp. 372–375. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/nineteenth-century-letters-1919/245/.

BibTeX@incollection{nineteenth-century-letters-1919-letter-0245,
  author    = {Charles Dickens},
  title     = {To John Forster · [in praise of the “life of goldsmith”], 22 April 1848},
  booktitle = {Nineteenth Century Letters},
  publisher = {New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1919},
  year      = {1919},
  pages     = {372--375},
  note      = {Selected and Edited, with an Introduction (The Modern Student's Library). Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/nineteenth-century-letters-1919/245/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/nineteenth-century-letters-1919/245/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.