Letter 16
“Baltimore May 11, 1829.
“Baltimore May 11, 1829.
“Dear Sir:—
“It occurred to me, after you left me this morning, that I was probably losing you a day on your journey to Philadelphia, by proposing to detain your poem even until tomorrow, as I understand the day-boat 1 has commenced her spring trips between the cities. I thought it due to your convenience, therefore, to read the poem at once, and send it tonight.
“I am sensible of the compliment you pay me in submitting it to my judgment and only regret that you have not a better counsellor. But the truth is that having never written poetry myself, nor read much poetry for many years, I consider myself as by no means a competent judge poems. This is no doubt an old-fashioned idea resulting from the causes I have mentioned, my ignorance of modern poetry and modern taste. You perceive therefore that I am not qualified to judge of the merits of your poem. It will, I know, please modern readers—the notes contain
[p. 132]a good deal of curious and useful information—but to deal candidly with you (as I am bound to do) I should doubt whether the poem will take with old-fashioned readers like myself. But this will be of little consequence—provided it be popular with modern readers—and of this, as I have already said, I am unqualified to judge. I would advise you, therefore, as a friend to get an introduction to Mr. Walsh or Mr. Hopkinson 2 or some other critic in Philadelphia, versed in modern”. . . . .
(Conclusion and signature missing).
It is easy to see between the lines of Mr. Wirt’s letter his struggle with the obscurities of “Al Aaraaf” but with a courtesy very beautiful from an old and distinguished man to an undeveloped youth, he gives Edgar’s work serious attention, reading it through at a sitting to avoid delay of a day in securing for it the criticism he had advised.
Encouraged by Wirt’s interest and Robert Walsh’s promise of notice of “Al Aaraaf” in the American Quarterly Review, on publication, Edgar Poe (though frankly quoting both Wirt and Walsh as to the difficulty of getting poetry published in America) writes Mr. Allan, on May 29: “I am now going to make a request different from any I have ever made.”
On the reverse of this letter Mr. Allan wrote “Replied to Monday, 8th June 1829 strongly censuring his conduct and refusing my aid.”
Notes
- 1This boat, according to an advertisement in the Baltimore Republican, July 13, 1829 (furnished by Dr. Mabbott) left the intersection of Light and Pratt Streets “at six o'clock in the morning.”
- 2Author of Hail Columbia—the name almost cut away supplied by Dr. Mabbott.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

