XLIX · James Russell Lowell to Ralph Waldo Emerson
In my class poem are a few lines about your “address.” My friends have expressed surprise…
XLIX
James Russell Lowell (1819–91), while still a boy and unknown to the literary world, had printed his Harvard Class Poem, in which, with more warmth than discretion, he made a rather bitter attack on Emerson. Hearing that his verses had met with some criticism on the ground of good taste, Lowell sent at once the following letter to the Concord essayist and poet.
James Russell Lowell to Ralph Waldo Emerson
Cambridge, Sept. 1st, 1838.
Dear Sir,—
In my class poem are a few lines about your “address.” My friends have expressed surprise that after I had enjoyed your hospitality and spoken so highly of you in private, I should have been so “ungrateful” as ever to have written anything of the kind. Could I have ever dreamed that a man’s private character should interfere with his public relations, I had never blotted paper so illy. But I really thought that I was doing rightly, for I consider it as virtual a lie to hold one’s tongue as to speak an untruth. I should have written the same of my own brother. Now, sir, I trouble you with this letter because I think you a man who would think nowise the worse of me for holding up my head and speaking the truth at any sacrifice. That I could wilfully malign a man whose salt I had eaten, and whose little child I had danced on my knee,— he must be a small man who would believe so small a thing of his fellow.
But this word “ingratitude” is a very harsh and grating word, and one which I hope would never be
[p. 91]laid to my charge since I stood at my mother's knee and learnt the first very alphabet, as it were, of goodness. I hope that if you have leisure, sir, you will answer this letter and put me at rest. I hope you will acquit me (for I do not still think there is aught to forgive or pardon, and I trust you will not after reading this letter) of all uncharitableness.
Of course no one can feel it as strongly as I do, for since my friends have hinted at this “ingratitude” I have felt a great deal, and scarcely dare to look at the Tennyson you lent me without expecting some of the devils on the cover to make faces at me.
I hope you will find time to answer this and that I may still enjoy your friendship and be able to take you by the hand and look you in the face, as honest man should to honest man.
I remain yours with respect,
James Russell Lowell.
P.S. I have sent with this a copy of my “poem”— if it be not too tiresome, you would perhaps think better of me, if you were to read it through. I am not silly enough to suppose that this can be of any importance to you (if, indeed, you ever heard of the passage I refer to), but it is of very great importance to me.
J. R. L.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

