LVIII · Henry van Dyke to Madison Cawein
Some procrastinating imp must have slipped into my fountain pen…
LVIII
Dr. Henry van Dyke, the well-known essayist and poet, writes to congratulate his friend, Mr. Madison Cawein, on the appearance of a new and brilliant volume of verse.
Henry van Dyke to Madison Cawein
Grand Hotel Alpina, Gstaad.
My dear Madison Cawein, —
Some procrastinating imp must have slipped into my fountain pen, to make me put off for so long a time the warm and hearty thanks which I have owed you since you sent me your New Poems. The other little volume by your young admirer had some pretty touches and sweet notes in it, — but here comes the master-lyrist and the disciple fades. This new book of yours is extraordinarily rich in music and colour. It is in these bits of pure song and absolute picture that I think you at your best. You have often words so vivid that they seem to convey an actual form, colour, movement, to the page: and you have sometimes cadences so delicately melodious that they seem to carry music with them. Next to this I put your elfin fancy, — for example as it plays in “Witchery.” In this volume your lyrics “with a story to tell” are very different in tone. There is a strong contrast between the Italian Renaissance of “That Night when I came to the Grange,” and the pure Kentucky of “The Old Gate made of Pickets,” and the anywhere of “Tramps.” But each one has its own kind of imaginative passion. You tend to the intense in your poetry, — always, — and sometimes I think you agitate Nature a little too much with piercing adjectives and violent
[p. 108]verbs. She has her wild moods, her fantastic hours, and these you render wonderfully. But most of the time she is as simple as a milk-maid and as great as the Venus of Melos, — sure of herself, inexhaustible, a little lazy, and full of intimate and tranquil charm. I don't mean to say that you fail to see or to express this ; but now and then you yield to the temptation to make her scream, — you " stab " the haws with a sunbeam, — or you give the innocent grasshopper a dagger, — or you make the poor bat very, very drunk. This is naughty, Madison, naughty, naughty ! But I 'll forgive you all these agitating escapades when you can write such a couplet as,
" While from a curved and azure jar
She poured the white moon and a star."
The sonnet sequence at the end of the book Mutatis Mutandis is full of curious strength. You have done well to use the double rhyme, the feminine ending, to mark the change of manner with the change of form. This is not like any of your other work, but it is very interesting, picturesque, and mordant. Sometimes I think the next famous poetry will be satire, and sometimes I think satire can never be great poetry.
But I congratulate you warmly on the book, — you have never made a better, — and I thank you for writing it and sending it to me.
Gertrude gives glowing accounts of your doings at Annisquam. Evidently you have all had a hilarious, resplendent, and expansive time. I shall write to her soon to narrate our placid experiences among the eternal hills of snow. Meantime our ship is getting
[p. 109]ready, for we sail on La Savoie, on the 4th of September, for home, — and it ’s glad we ’ll be to get there.
Yours ever,
Henry van Dyke.
August 23, 1909.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.


