II. · To a German Propagandist of Henry George's Views.

a German Propagandist of Henry George's Views

It is with particular pleasure that I hasten to answer your letter…

1897Printed pp. 215–218

II.

To a German Propagandist of Henry George's Views.

It is with particular pleasure that I hasten to answer your letter, and say that I have known of Henry George since the appearance of his Social Problems. I read that book and was struck by the justice of his main thought—by the exceptional manner (unparalleled in scientific literature), clear, popular and forcible, in which he stated his cause—and especially by (what is also exceptional in scientific literature) the Christian spirit that permeates the whole work. After reading it I went back to his earlier Progress and Poverty, and still more deeply appreciated the importance of its author's activity.

You ask what I think of Henry George's activity, and of his Single-Tax system. My opinion is the following :

Humanity constantly advances: on the one hand clearing its consciousness and conscience, and on the other hand rearranging its modes of life to suit this changing consciousness. Thus, at each period of the life of humanity, the double process goes on : the clearing up

[p. 216]

of conscience, and the incorporation into life of what has been made clear to conscience.

At the end of the eighteenth century and the commencement of the nineteenth, a clearing up of conscience took place in Christendom with reference to the labouring classes—who lived under various forms of slavery—and this was followed by a corresponding readjustment of the forms of social life, to suit this clearer consciousness : namely, the abolition of slavery, and the organization of free wage-labour in its place. At the present time an enlightenment of men's consciences is going on in relation to the way land is used ; and soon, it seems to me, a practical application of this new consciousness must follow.

And in this process (the enlightenment of conscience as to the utilization of land, and the practical application of that new consciousness), which is one of the chief problems of our time, the leader and organizer of the movement was and is Henry George. In this lies his immense, his pre-eminent, importance. He has helped by his excellent books, both to clear men's minds and consciences on this question, and to place it on a practical footing.

But in relation to the abolition of the shameful right to own landed estates, something is occurring similar to what happened (within our own recollection) with reference to the abolition of serfdom. The Government and the governing classes—knowing that their position and privileges are bound up with the land question—pretend that they are preoccupied with the welfare of the people, organizing savings banks for workmen, factory inspection, income taxes, even eight-hours working days—and carefully ignore the land question, or even, aided by compliant science, which will demonstrate anything they like, declare that the expropriation of the land is useless, harmful, and impossible.

Just the same thing occurs, as occurred in connection with slavery. At the end of the eighteenth and the beginning of the nineteenth centuries, men had long felt that slavery was a terrible anachronism, revolting

[p. 217]

to the human soul; but pseudo-religion and pseudo-science demonstrated that slavery was not wrong, that it was necessary, or at least that it was premature to abolish it. The same thing is now being repeated with reference to landed property. As before, pseudo-religion and pseudo-science demonstrate that there is nothing wrong in the private ownership of landed estates, and that there is no need to abolish the present system.

One would think it would be plain to every educated man of our time that an exclusive control of land by people who do not work on it, but who prevent hundreds and thousands of poor families from using it, is a thing as plainly bad and shameful as it was to own slaves; yet we see educated, refined aristocrats—English, Austrian, Prussian, and Russian—making use of this cruel and shameful right, and not only not feeling ashamed, but feeling proud of it.

Religion blesses such possessions, and the science of political economy demonstrates that the present state of things is the one that should exist for the greatest benefit of mankind.

The service rendered by Henry George is, that he has not only mastered the sophistries with which religion and science try to justify private ownership of land, and simplified the question to the uttermost, so that it is impossible not to admit the wrongfulness of land-ownership—unless one simply stops one's ears—but he was also the first to show how the question can be practically solved. He first gave a clear and direct reply to the excuses, used by the enemies of every reform, to the effect that the demands of progress are unpractical and inapplicable dreams.

Henry George's plan destroys that excuse, by putting the question in such a form that a committee might be assembled to-morrow to discuss the project and to convert it into law. In Russia, for instance, the discussion of land purchase, or of nationalizing the land without compensation, could begin to-morrow; and the project might—after undergoing various vicissitudes—

[p. 218]

be carried into operation, as occurred thirty-three years ago* with the project for the emancipation of the serfs.

The need of altering the present system has been explained, and the possibility of the change has been shown (there may be alterations and amendments of the Single-Tax system, but its fundamental idea is practicable) ; and, therefore, it will be impossible for people not to do what their reason demands. It is only necessary that this thought should become public opinion ; and in order that it may become public opinion it must be spread abroad and explained— which is just what you are doing, and is a work with which I sympathize with my whole soul, and in which I wish you success.

[1897.]

Notes

  1. *The Emancipation of the Serfs in Russia was decreed in 1861, and was accomplished during the following few years.

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 227 of the 1903 edition (printed page 215), showing letter II. To a German Propagandist of Henry George's Views.
Printed page 215 · scan leaf 227 of 388Open the full scan
Scan leaf 228 of the 1903 edition (printed page 216), showing letter II. To a German Propagandist of Henry George's Views.
Printed page 216 · scan leaf 228 of 388Open the full scan
Scan leaf 229 of the 1903 edition (printed page 217), showing letter II. To a German Propagandist of Henry George's Views.
Printed page 217 · scan leaf 229 of 388Open the full scan
Scan leaf 230 of the 1903 edition (printed page 218), showing letter II. To a German Propagandist of Henry George's Views.
Printed page 218 · scan leaf 230 of 388Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter II. To a German Propagandist of Henry George's Views of 13 · printed pp. 215–218 · scan leaf 227 of 388

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
Essays and Letters, translated by Aylmer Maude (The World's Classics, XLVI), 1903, pp. 215–218.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationLetter to a German Propagandist of Henry George's Views, 1897, “II. · To a German Propagandist of Henry George's Views.”. In Essays and Letters, translated by Aylmer Maude (The World's Classics, XLVI) (London: Grant Richards, Leicester Square, 1903), pp. 215–218. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/tolstoy-essays-letters-1903/9/.

BibTeX@incollection{tolstoy-essays-letters-1903-letter-0009,
  author    = {},
  title     = {II. · To a German Propagandist of Henry George's Views., 1897},
  booktitle = {Essays and Letters},
  publisher = {London: Grant Richards, Leicester Square, 1903},
  year      = {1903},
  pages     = {215--218},
  note      = {Translated by Aylmer Maude (The World's Classics, XLVI). Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/tolstoy-essays-letters-1903/9/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/tolstoy-essays-letters-1903/9/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.