Letter 83
Do not speak of your letters as "babble," my brave and worthy philosopher…
Lausanne, Bed; whence I can see ten miles of Lake.
January 29, 1758.
Do not speak of your letters as "babble," my brave and worthy philosopher: it is essential, if you please, to discuss and understand the business with which they deal.
Geneva is making a fine profession of faith: you will have the satisfaction of having compelled the heretics to publish a catechism. They complain
[p. 165]of the article on Actors, included in that on Geneva: but you added these few lines on comedy at the request of the citizens themselves. Thus, you have merely, on the one hand, yielded to the persuasions of the middle class, and, on the other, have repeated the opinion of the ministers—an opinion which has been published in the text-book of one of their theologians, and was publicly discussed everywhere before you spoke.
When I begged you to resume your work on the Encyclopædia, I did not know to what a vile excess libel had been carried, and I was far from suspecting that it was actually prompted by the authorities. I wrote you a long letter by Mme. de Fontaine: she is your neighbour: cannot you manage to go and see her?
It would be sad to think you were leaving the Encyclopædia on account of the article on Geneva, as rumour pretends: but it would be sadder still that you should continue to be the victim of annoyances which, in proportion as they are dishonouring to our nation, should rouse you to rebellion.
Are you in close co-operation with M. Diderot and your other colleagues? “A three-fold cord is not quickly broken.”
When you all state simultaneously that you will not work without a guarantee of the honourable
[p. 166]freedom which is essential to you, and of the protection to which you are entitled, surely it is not doubtful that you will be implored not to deprive France of a monument necessary to her glory? The clamour will pass: the work will remain.
If you all abandoned the work together, making your own stipulations, that might be well: it would be very unpleasant for you to leave it by yourself: the head must not cut itself off from the body.
When you produce the first volume, add a preface to it which will shame those cowards who have permitted the only writers now working for the glory of the nation to be insulted: and, for God's sake, stop those feeble declamations which are being inserted in your Encyclopædia. Do not give our enemies the right to complain that those who have been unsuccessful, or a dead failure, in the arts can take upon themselves to make the rules for those arts and set those rules by their own absurd fancies. Banish the feeble moralising which pads several articles. The reader wants to know the different acceptations of a word, and detests trivial and commonplace authorities quoted in support of it. What obliges you to disgrace the Encyclopædia with this mass of twaddle and rubbish which gives so good a handle to the critics? and why join beggar's fustian to your cloth-of-gold? Be absolute masters of it, or abandon the whole thing. Unfortunate
[p. 167]sons of Paris, you should have undertaken this work in a free country! You have laboured for the booksellers: they take the profits, and leave you the persecution. All this—which I regret with my whole heart for your sakes—makes me find my retirement delightful. Would to God you had never seen a minister when you were here! Keep me posted in everything, I implore you.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.



